ForumsPopular MediaIs Jimi Hendrix a Little too Overrated?

45 10754
bacobit
offline
bacobit
1,671 posts
Nomad

I'm not saying the guy wasn't a Great Guitarist, He deffinatly had huge influence on Music and his improvs were great. But, to be honest, I don't think he's thee Single greatest guitarist ever, he's way up there, sure, But not the greatest.
I know I'm going to get some bad feedback, but I can take it.

  • 45 Replies
ilberic
offline
ilberic
858 posts
Jester

I believe he is overrated, yes. I do believe he was a great guitar player, but not as great as he's made out to be. I think there are much better guitar players out there than him.

I have a personal preference for a "cleaner" sound than what Jimi typically put out. If my preference was for a "dirtier" sound, then probably Jimi would be my favorite.

My feelings towards him have been inflated due to the fact that he is constantly shoved down peoples throats and said to be the ultimate guitar god, when in reality, that's a personal opinion. I don't fault anyone for believing he is the best of all time, but don't bother trying to make me think the same.

bacobit
offline
bacobit
1,671 posts
Nomad

Also using the tremolo would be a little awkward


True, though I'm sure he had a custom lefty bridge put in.

Its not because of the speed of playing or technics,


Well of course, if it were all speed, every metalhead guitarist and their brother would rule the top 10.

To me, it's not the skill, it's the songwriting ability. You could write the world greatest melody using only 4 notes (A Hyperbole, may or not be possible).
Guitarstring
offline
Guitarstring
52 posts
Nomad

He is one of the greatest guitarists in the whole world, of course people gonna be so whatever abut him.

Kevin4762
offline
Kevin4762
2,420 posts
Nomad

We can all agree Jimi Hendrix was talented, whether you don't like him or not, consider him the greatest of all time, he was talented. You can't take away from him that.

Zydrate
offline
Zydrate
383 posts
Farmer

I am not a fan.

wallydog
offline
wallydog
33 posts
Shepherd

I have to say, he was talented, but his playing was a bit sloppy. He was very influential, yes, but he's been outdistanced by more recent guitarists. I'd say that he's up there, but overrated.

Kevin4762
offline
Kevin4762
2,420 posts
Nomad

I have to say, he was talented

k
his playing was a bit sloppy.


In what way?

He was very influential,


k

he's been outdistanced by more recent guitarists.


Like who?

I'd say that he's up there, but overrated.


Why do you think he is overrated? You have, so far, only said he was sloppy and that is not supported by anything.
Bearsal1121
offline
Bearsal1121
290 posts
Nomad

He is not. Jimi Hendrix is the one who revolutionized guitar playing, played around with hundreds of unseen techniques, invented real rock guitar. He was not over rated at all, and in fact he might be even under rated. He doesn't even keep the volume of his guitar high in most of his songs, and you miss out on the real genius behind: Voodoo Child and Hey Joe.

He should be the most respected guitarist ever.

metalwill
offline
metalwill
147 posts
Shepherd

Hendrix is one of the most overrated guitarists ever. He was a very sloppy blues rock player. He really didn't do anything complicated or complex. I believe his early death is what has made him as iconic as he is (the same as people like Kurt Cobain and Janis Joplin).

There are numerous people who are/have been much better players than Hendrix and have done more for the guitar world than he ever could.

Kevin4762
offline
Kevin4762
2,420 posts
Nomad

He was a very sloppy blues rock player.


Prove it.

He really didn't do anything complicated or complex.


Are you kidding? It is almost impossible to play any of his songs without some serious skill.

I believe his early death is what has made him as iconic as he is (the same as people like Kurt Cobain and Janis Joplin).


No. He was iconic before his death, just like Lady Gaga. She is iconic and if she died tomorrow due to a drug overdose, she would remain iconic.

There are numerous people who are/have been much better players than Hendrix and have done more for the guitar world than he ever could.


For example?

**** hipsters.
jacksonghuntington
offline
jacksonghuntington
347 posts
Nomad

uh to many people are hatin him here... im not even gona comment... excuse me while i... kiss the sky.

deathmask
offline
deathmask
59 posts
Shepherd

Great guy, though a bit too overrated

SuperRaven
offline
SuperRaven
128 posts
Nomad

Another one is:
Is Chuck Norris Overrated??? i wonder.

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

Hendrix is one of the most overrated guitarists ever. He was a very sloppy blues rock player. He really didn't do anything complicated or complex. I believe his early death is what has made him as iconic as he is (the same as people like Kurt Cobain and Janis Joplin).


lol you got to think of the time era. this was in the 60s. the stuff he did with a guitar nobody had ever seen before, its not to complex NOW but back then he was the bees knees.

There are numerous people who are/have been much better players than Hendrix and have done more for the guitar world than he ever could.


i know, and im sure lots of others do also, that doesnt take away from the fact that hes not overrated, what he did for rock guitar was greater then ANY other rock guitarist. he INVENTED many of the techniques we currently use today. he was an icon.
Showing 31-44 of 45