For whomever puppets Arasys today, she will keep acting all sweet and innocent until she figures out the others are Evil, then she tries to get them to assassinate the Mayor for being too good. If the Bard asks why she took the stuff and she is still acting nice, shee says it was all just so pretty and she couldn't help herself. If they ask about the pp, she says it was a sp. If the Bard keeps acting stupid, fake seduction then kill him in a back alley.
If you do well enough, you may be rewarded. If you fail, never again.