Forums → The Tavern → [necro] Who Wins? Pie vs Cake

Pie is the winner because cake have very few flavors while pie is numerous flavors that is someone doesnlt like one kind of pie, they might try other kinds and like them. whereas with cake, if u conly like one type, u wouldnt like any other type, for there is only one type

@GhostOfMatrix

What to you mean by only one type of cake? Just type in cake in Wikipedia and you'll see lots of types of cake. Like my moms donut cake, pound cake, yeast cake, sponge cake, chocolate cake, vanilla cake, ice cream cake...ect
And you can add frostings. I don't think you can do that with pie IMAO.

cake defiantly would beat pie any day. cake has all differnt varieties (chocolate,yellow,white,ice cream....) and what does pie hhave, fruit fillings. so cake defiantly would win

Cake! You dont see pie being celebrated.

When We Reach 100 posts we shall see who AG members choose!

what about a boston cream pie? those are awesome.

9 words

boston creme pies are awesome, but you could easily fill a cake with boston creme as well.

what about a boston cream pie?

you could easily fill a cake with boston creme as well.

I don't think you can do that with pie IMAO

That's what filling is for, moreover meatcake sounds odd.

beefcake sounds odd. meatcakes sound like epanadas.

cake, cuz pie can get old

And I rlly dont see what so special about pie

I change my vote. The only types of cake I like are cheesecake and ice cream cake, while I like almost all types of pie.

So I change to pie.

cake cake cake..much better then pie i mean i like chocolate pie and hersheys sundae pie but cake is beast theres vanilla,chocolate,strawberry and so many others not to mention the various flavor icings you can have and topings like sprinkles and gummy candys and theres even tons of different kinds of icecream cake..and people still post on this topic pie?

hey hey hey cake always wins