Forums → The Tavern → [necro] Who Wins? Pie vs Cake

I really don't prefer any of those, just plain gross.

P.S. 100th post! XD

Cheese cake wins, it's a pie that passes itself off as cake.

Pie. Cake is just nasty.

I like coconut pie, and lemon merange pie.

cake cake cake..much better then pie i mean i like chocolate pie and hersheys sundae pie but cake is beast theres vanilla,chocolate,strawberry and so many others not to mention the various flavor icings you can have and topings like sprinkles and gummy candys and theres even tons of different kinds of icecream cake..and people still post on this topic pie?

Cake. it tastes great. while pies usally taste from okay to bad. ice cream cake beats any pie, but some cakes are just terrible. they used to taste better.

pie, hands down... sooo many flavors so little time

Cake is like 90 percent air... pie is 100 percent delicious, plus its versatile, you can put fruit or meat in it...
pie wins

cake because i dont like the crust on pies... iknow im wierd

I don't like either very much. But if I had to choose I would probably pick Pie.

I'm pretty sure cheesecake is a cake.

PIE! ALL MUST BOW TO ITS ALL HOLE-Y CRUST (to prepare well, poke holes in the crust with a fork before baking) ITS FILLING SHALL BRING PEACE TO YOUR MIND AND SPIRIT!

Pie in general. But some cakes taste great and then i would prefer cake.

I'm startled that no one else made this joke so here it comes:

The cake is a lie!

I don't eat pie very often but my dad's fruit pie is scrumches and cake can taste horrible If not well made. So it's a tie for me.

Pie. I don't really like cake. It tastes weird.