Forums → The Tavern → [necro] Who Wins? Pie vs Cake

I don't like pies and I never have. When I think of pies, I think of fruits. I don't like mixing my fruits with crumbs, so cake. Don't get me wrong, I love fruits, but I just don't like them in pies.

Could I merit a post, I would have merited this.

I vote cookies, simply because I can.

what if..the cake is a pie?

I've never really liked either.
Cake is just a bit too heavy for me, doesn't digest well.
While pie, it just doesn't go with fruit, it leaves a sort of sweet or bitter taste in your mouth, for me anyways.

Ummmm...Ummmm...they are both good, I can't choose! I love apple pie and others but cake is soooooooo good too, german chocolate is delicious! So I say....both!

On a radio program called the Debators, they argued about that and one guy said "PIE!!! What's it hiding? What lurks beneath it's crust? WE DON'T KNOW DO WE!?!?"


I agree with him.

I agree with Geoff from roosterteeth (yay red vs blue)
Pie > cake

This useful and well-planned venn-diagram should provide the answer to why one may or may not be better than the other.

How many times am I going to say it PIE WINS

Well since the cake is a lie the pie obviously wins.

Obviously that venn diagram makes perfect sense. The only thing I can't draw from it is which one wins?

http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.com/2010/03/pie-verus-cake-scientific-approach.html

That is all.

http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.com/2010/03/pie-verus-cake-scientific-approach.html

CAKE.
I hate pies.

CAKE WINS.
CAAAAAAAKE

CAKE.
I hate pies.

CAKE WINS.
CAAAAAAAKE