I wouldn't have thought so either. I personally prefer pie because there are more kinds that I like. In the case of cake, I only like chocolate. Or maybe tiramisu. For pie there is pumpkin, pecan, chocolate mousse, cherry, blueberry...need I go on?
it depends what kind of cake or pie ice cream cake beats apple pie but pumpkin pie beats white cake with choclate frosting you have to be more spicific