Ben and Jerrys Caramel choo choo or cookie dough. I prefer the cookie dough flavouring but the chocolate caramel chunks in the choo choo are incredible.
We have another thread semi-like this, but it got locked.
Yeah. The reason it got locked is because it was a 'this vs that' thread and people only had tried one of the two brands and couldn't make a comparison. This one's open to all brands and all flavors as well.
Also I found out why I've never heard of Mayfield. It's only sold in ten states, mostly in the southeast: Tennessee, Georgia, Alabama, South Carolina, North Carolina, Florida, Kentucky, Virginia, Ohio, and Mississippi.