ForumsWEPR[necro] Ask a Muslim

558 134998
Reiki000
offline
Reiki000
232 posts
Nomad

Any questions about Islam, ask it here?

Greetings

  • 558 Replies
loco5
offline
loco5
16,287 posts
Peasant

i dunno if this has already been asked but, how do you feel about people who have/ want to depict Mohammed in a cartoon or a show or something like that?

thepunisher93
offline
thepunisher93
1,826 posts
Nomad

may god forgive me i must have mixed it up with some other verse

thepunisher93
offline
thepunisher93
1,826 posts
Nomad

Hadith: The persons who will receive the severest punishment will be painters.
Bukhari-Tasawir

4:48 - God does not forgive who set up partners to God, but He forgives anything else to whom He pleases.

here it means god will forgive all other sins if he wants to but will not forgive shirk.that is he may or may not forgive painting.
ahadiths have levels of certificate like
NONE:these r considered lie.
WEAK:can b possibly true.
AGREED BY ALL:all 6 hadeeth writers agree on it being true.
thepunisher93
offline
thepunisher93
1,826 posts
Nomad

i dunno if this has already been asked but, how do you feel about people who have/ want to depict Mohammed in a cartoon or a show or something like that?

if someone in muslim country would have done that government would have punished him.
we muslims keep holy prophet even above our families
just tell how ull feel if someone draws insulting images of your father
loco5
offline
loco5
16,287 posts
Peasant

if someone in muslim country would have done that government would have punished him.
we muslims keep holy prophet even above our families
just tell how ull feel if someone draws insulting images of your father


what if it wasn't insulting, say people use computer technologies to get an accurate description of the prophet Mohammed and what he looked like back then?
thepunisher93
offline
thepunisher93
1,826 posts
Nomad

sharaia law icludes quraan and hadeeths there are many matters quran is silent on like punishment of a gay etc

thepunisher93
offline
thepunisher93
1,826 posts
Nomad

punishment of a insulter of holy prophet
(which he established as killing prep

thepunisher93
offline
thepunisher93
1,826 posts
Nomad

he resented painting of a living creature so we take it a\\s insult if someone draws him no matter what

jt25rox
offline
jt25rox
332 posts
Peasant

wen do u get ur 72 virgins and r they good looking

thebluerabbit
offline
thebluerabbit
5,340 posts
Farmer

not to bother you or something but could you keep your messages in one comment please punisher?

Armed_Blade
offline
Armed_Blade
1,482 posts
Shepherd

sharaia law icludes quraan and hadeeths there are many matters quran is silent on like punishment of a gay etc


Dude, I need to lay this out flat for you.
Its spelled Sharia.
It isn't some codified law scripture, you can't find it hanging on the wall of a museum like the US Constitution.
That being said, it is subject to interpretation. Not all Hadith's are reported true, because after all, they were orally transmitted. People rely on using links between Hadiths [If more than one historical figure says the same thing].
So Sharia law isn't 'defined' at all. So it really doesn't say much.
If a country chooses to run in Sharia law, then it also needs theocratic interpretation from religious officials.

what if it wasn't insulting, say people use computer technologies to get an accurate description of the prophet Mohammed and what he looked like back then?


It isn't that we fear him so much or that we deem him sacred that we shouldn't draw/depict him -- that would kill the whole monotheistic idea.
Our hope is to not make him an icon/idol of the religion. We don't want to make him more than what he was, which is a human prophet. We live by his standards not because we think he was a God, but because we think he lived his life to the fullest extend of Islam. [Being a prophet and all that makes sense].
For this reason, we would prefer no drawings/depictions of his to be made, simply because we don't like it.
I don't think any Muslims I know in the West will ever go on a killing montage because someone draws it, and we all comprehend the idea of free speech.
Making all of these drawings and causing so much hype regarding any depiction of the prophet has given westerners a sense that Islam has almost nothing to do with being a religion and has almost everything to do with our prophet.

punishment of a insulter of holy prophet


See, like this law. It is totally open to interpretation. How can anyone honestly believe this when the Qur'an itself says that this shouldn't be done? Clearly it makes sense that the Hadith that this was founded on, or the interpretation of the theocratic official was misguided. Islam is not led by Imams and many people seem to not know that.

wen do u get ur 72 virgins and r they good looking

The concept of 72 virgins doesn't make any sense at all. There's a notion in Surah Rahman that states those entering paradise will get splendid companions, recreations of those dead beforehand, usually of equal age. It doesn't really specify who they are in any or all context, so to assume you just get 72 virgins to bang doesn't make any sense.
thepunisher93
offline
thepunisher93
1,826 posts
Nomad

armed blade u r right
but some hadiths on which all 6 of scholars are agreed upon become a permenant part of sharia law

thepunisher93
offline
thepunisher93
1,826 posts
Nomad

âThe punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger, and strive with might for mischief through the land is: execution, or crucifixion, or the cutting off of hands and feet from opposite sides, or exile from the land: that is their disgrace in this world, and a heavy punishment is theirs in the Hereafter;â [Surah Al-Maidah 5:33]. In Islam, a person who has committed blasphemy can either be killed or crucified, or his opposite hands and feet can be cut off, or he can be exiled from that land. On the other hand, in other religions there is no other option except capital punishment. Islam at least has four options of punishment for an act of blasphemy.
[url=http://www.islamicvoice.com/April2006/QuestionHour-DrZakirNaik/]

Reiki000
offline
Reiki000
232 posts
Nomad

i dunno if this has already been asked but, how do you feel about people who have/ want to depict Mohammed in a cartoon or a show or something like that?

Becuase the Prophet(pbuh) was scared that people would take him as an idol. Taking another idol next to God is a big sin.

Greetings
Reiki000
offline
Reiki000
232 posts
Nomad

i dunno if this has already been asked but, how do you feel about people who have/ want to depict Mohammed in a cartoon or a show or something like that?

Sorry for the double post, but I forgot to say my own opinion. Why should I care. As God says, do what you want to. I'm not gonna burn some flags because someone draws him.

Greetings
Showing 286-300 of 558