ForumsPopular MediaWhovians put your opinion here

76 21958
exitpathuser
offline
exitpathuser
154 posts
Nomad

Anything Doctor Who from 1- to present seasons. Your opinions, ideas, comments on the Daleks all appreciated.

  • 76 Replies
Dewi1066
offline
Dewi1066
539 posts
Nomad

Yes, I do.

No idea what Eccleston is like privately, he may be nicest bloke in the world, but his acting career has lurched from one role to another, nothing particularly groundbreaking and almost always ends up (TV wise) with him wanting to leave the show so he isn't typecast. The British TV production companies are now reluctant to hire him as a result, as who wants to go to the trouble of hiring someone, developing a character and promoting them, only to have it thrown back in their face by someone who thinks he's better than the role.

His appearances in films haven't warmed him to Hollywood or anyone else for that matter. He lacks presence on the screen and delivers his lines in a wooden fashion.

With Doctor Who, he didn't really last a season as such. It was leaked very quickly after he became Doctor Who that he would only be doing one series, the excuse he gave, he didn't want to be typecast. Later it was alleged he left due to exhaustion, and I think Alan Davis was the first to give him some stick about it in the British media. 5 years later with his career not doing terribly well, Eccleston decides to give an interview to the BBC (linked above) and tell everyone it wasn't his fault he left Doctor Who, it was the naughty crew members who didn't like him.

So, yes, I think he's a bad actor. Not just for his acting, but the way he interacts with production companies, film crews and how he has a prima donna fit when the show he's on becomes popular, believing his own hype and screaming typecast to his agent.

daleks
offline
daleks
3,766 posts
Chamberlain

I have never seen Eccleston in anything besides Doctor Who.

I have seen Tennent on Top Gear and in the 4th Harry Potter movie.

exitpathuser
offline
exitpathuser
154 posts
Nomad

Tennet is in 4th harry potter as who?

MoonFairy
offline
MoonFairy
3,386 posts
Shepherd

Tennant*
He is probably my favorite, I really enjoyed how he took hold of the character. He's a vampire hunter in te movie Fright Night :P

daleks
offline
daleks
3,766 posts
Chamberlain

Tennet is in 4th harry potter as who?

Barty Crouch Jr. The only time you get to see him is at the very end of the movie. And it is pretty hard to tell.
Tennant*

Thanks. My spelling sucks.
Kyouzou
offline
Kyouzou
5,061 posts
Jester

Apparently Fright Night was absolute amazing, I'm taking Chris Hardwick's word for it at the moment. Also, interesting tidbit about Tennant, he was first offered the job when working with the producer on the set of Casanova, somewhat hilarious considering his string of female companions on Dr. Who.

daleks
offline
daleks
3,766 posts
Chamberlain

For those of you that have seen the old Doctor Whos, are there any aliens you want to come back in the new series?

unknown456
offline
unknown456
47 posts
Peasant

Love DW. right now I've seen more than 10 of the classic series episodes, the 1996 movie, and all of the new series Who. Also is it just me or do some people seem a bit clingy to a doctor. I mean its fine to have your favorite doctor but some people really bash basically any other doctor besides their favorite (especially poor Matt Smith who I think is doing a great job).

unknown456
offline
unknown456
47 posts
Peasant

Also I think it would be neat to see the Ice Warriors come back.

unknown456
offline
unknown456
47 posts
Peasant

One more comment, this is how it goes for me William Hartnell is The Doctor, David Tennant is ONE of the greatest doctors, Matt Smith is MY doctor.

exitpathuser
offline
exitpathuser
154 posts
Nomad

I salute whoever was alive during the original D who. I will watch the old ones (someday.) Tennat for president of Whovian post.

daleks
offline
daleks
3,766 posts
Chamberlain

(especially poor Matt Smith who I think is doing a great job).

I think he is doing great. The writing is what I don't like.
Matt Smith is MY doctor.

Is he the first Doctor you saw? Usually your doctor is the one that you first saw.
exitpathuser
offline
exitpathuser
154 posts
Nomad

Unless you saw Eccleston first and then Tennat.

SacretNight
offline
SacretNight
15 posts
Nomad

I love it when Matt Smith is the doctor, I also love it his companions Amy and Rory, but I think Amy is very cute.

Pixie214
offline
Pixie214
5,838 posts
Peasant

Just watched the trailer for the next series looks ok. Looks like it's just showing some clips from the first few episodes. Doesn't show anything to do with Jenna-Louise Coleman but I assume she hasn't filmed anything yet. But it should be fun too have Mark Williams and David Bradley in.

Showing 61-75 of 76