ForumsWorld Events, Politics, Religion, Etc.Why are People nowadays so corrupted?

34 5965
mbbs112
offline
mbbs112
196 posts
1,110

I wonder why People are so corrupted nowadays ,why not just share or use the barter system like back then?

  • 34 Replies
HahiHa
offline
HahiHa
6,422 posts
14,255

Before asking why that is so, I would like you to convince me of the veracity of the statement "people are more corrupt nowadays".

Personally, I would argue that our current society is just as corrupt, if not even less, that some ancient historical societies. In my opinion modern standards about corruption are more pronounced, partly due to globalisation.

Note: I agree that corruption is a problem and still widespread on different levels and different countries. All I'm saying is that I don't think previous societies to be so much better.

Kasic
offline
Kasic
5,742 posts
3,195

People today aren't any more corrupt than they were in ages before. Reading any history book makes that very clear. As for the barter system, what does that even have to do with corruption?

EmperorPalpatine
offline
EmperorPalpatine
9,477 posts
2,320

why not just share

Because resources are limited and people want to use them for different things to meet different goals.

or use the barter system like back then?

Do you really want to buy a computer with pigs that you don't have? Every time you want to buy something, you'd need to negotiate on what to buy it with, and it's always on the seller's terms. If the seller received too much of an item, like corn, he won't accept any more corn payments. If that's all you have, even if you have tons, you're screwed and can't buy that product or use that service. Apply this to medicine. If you don't have chickens, too bad, you die.
Nurvana
offline
Nurvana
2,597 posts
1,635

, I would like you to convince me of the veracity of the statement "people are more corrupt nowadays".


I think he's just making the common mistake a lot of people make of observing unsettling things in society and assuming it means we as a people have become more corrupt. Yes, there are some shady things going on right now but that's been the case for as long as organized society has existed.
Freakenstein
offline
Freakenstein
9,684 posts
3,430

I wonder why People are so corrupted nowadays ,why not just share or use the barter system like back then?


Money is a Type-1 (Global) bartering system. You're still bartering, but with money.

Society, especially the economic society was much more corrupt back then. It had to take government regulation to state "no, you can't sell rotten foods stricken with disease or placebo tonics as the cures to cancer".

Ironically, the government back then was riddled with "hey, I'll give you a job if you place a vote for me.", but only if you were a white male Christian.
Nurvana
offline
Nurvana
2,597 posts
1,635

he common mistake a lot of people make


So redundant I actually just died.

Ironically, the government back then was riddled with "hey, I'll give you a job if you place a vote for me.", but only if you were a white male Christian.


True but not 100% corruption; partly a lack of progressive thinking in general.
mbbs112
offline
mbbs112
196 posts
1,110

Guys read the history of pakistan from when it was made then youll know what i mean and currently the president we have isnt one of the brightest either xD

bigjacob
offline
bigjacob
589 posts
2,025

Mbbs, that's a rhetorical question. Corruption has been around since humans first began to develop advanced civilizations. I wouldn't be surprised if chieftains were making shady deals with other tribes and selling people out for personal gain.

Corruption is simply too vast of a problem to control, and very unpredictable. You aren't born, destined to set up a front for some illegal business or the likes, it's a matter of circumstance, DNA, and situation.

And as others have said, bartering is simply too unreliable as long as the purchase is made on the supplier's terms. At least if you have the money for something, you can be mostly assured you'll get it. But what if you desperately need some life saving medicine from the local pharmacist, but he demands an ivory made kazoo and, oh no, you don't have one lying around? (Okay, that was too bizarre of an example. The principle still applies, however.)

Nerdsoft
offline
Nerdsoft
1,294 posts
380

Barter. Works well, don't it?
Pig farmer has meat, wants bread. Another guy has bread, wants milk. Dairy farmer has milk, wants meat. They all get what they want. Enter the city. Corn farmer has corn, wants a plough. The shoemaker wants corn, the tailor wants sausages, the butcher wants shoes, the blacksmith wants bread, the wheat farmer...
But wait! "I don't want corn," says the baker. "Besides, I haven't any wheat!"
"But the wheat farmer wants an ivory kazoo!"
"Tough!"
"But... how will I pay the blacksmith?"
"Your problem, buddy."
Enter money.
"Hey baker! I don't need your bread, I've paid the blacksmith with money!"
"That's okay! I bought the wheat from this farmer who was busy playing a kazoo made of ivory!"
So really, money makes things a lot simpler. It's an inevitable development. With cities comes money.

goumas13
offline
goumas13
4,895 posts
22,165

Barter Economies are quite wasteful. The "double coincidence of wants", which is implied by a barter economy involves a considerable cost of valuable resources (commodities and time), hence money emerges out of the attempt to save on these resources.

Anyway, I obviously don't agree with the statement that money is the source of all corruption and that barter economies somehow function better.

danielo
offline
danielo
1,782 posts
600

Curroption is a natural thing. Who dont want to help his friends and family, or take care for themselve?

The government workers work with HUGE amounts of money. Most of them get much much much less money then that. Its tempting. It start with small things, like a gift of a bottle of scotch or 2 tickets for a concert. Then it grow bigger and bigger.

metalplastic
offline
metalplastic
191 posts
0

Oh, corruption about money? If it's about that then it's because of the insatiable hunger for "more" I guess. Where "more" can be almost anything that money can buy.
I myself am not corrupted for money (if that's a right term) but I'm corrupted for something else...

roydotor2000
offline
roydotor2000
344 posts
590

the only treatment is discipline and responsibility, 'Cuz great power comes great responsibility.

danielo
offline
danielo
1,782 posts
600

Oh no you didnt!

Isnt there a rule against using that cliche in the forums?

But i guese its true.

Like the romans didnt did the same. Or the feudal lords. Oor anyone else in any other period.

roydotor2000
offline
roydotor2000
344 posts
590

Isnt there a rule against using that cliche in the forums?


not sure
Showing 1-15 of 34