ForumsWEPRSouthern Pride and the Rebel Flag

32 49038
Sonatavarius
offline
Sonatavarius
1,322 posts
Farmer

http://hdwpapers.com/walls/confederate_rebel_flag_wallpaper_hd-other.jpg

I believe I may have started a similar thread a long time ago, but I'm too lazy to find it. I think that the normals nowadays are different than back then (save for a few usernames I've never not seen floating around)...so I'm going to start a new discussion.

I will start with a question. What comes to your mind when you see the Rebel flag / Southern Cross / Southern Battle flag or some image representing/incorporating it?

http://farm3.staticflickr.com/2323/2280804506_8da895158c_o.jpg
^the flag of the state of Mississippi

Does the flag incite rage? Does it excite a little southern pride in you? Does it represent hatred and suffering to you?....and why? What is your opinion of the people who would desire to fly it in public?

I'll leave it here for now and wait to see if anyone is interested in the subject before I ramble any further

  • 32 Replies
Sonatavarius
offline
Sonatavarius
1,322 posts
Farmer

I haven't reread what I've said up until now, but I think I've mentioned that supposedly a lot of prominent southern figures were opposed to slavery. Are you sure it was a war to keep slavery as much as it was a war to maintain greater state independence from the federal government? Rumor has it that Grant kept his slaves til they made him drop the act.

It doesn't matter where the flag flew? So you're telling me that you refuse to see the bad things associated with one flag, but you can only see the bad associated with another? If the flags were people, then you'd be a discrimihating racist.

rychus
offline
rychus
1,282 posts
Farmer

So you're telling me that you refuse to see the bad things associated with one flag, but you can only see the bad associated with another?


It doesn't matter where the flag flew, its what it represents.


I never said that I was ignoring what bad things are associated with our current flag.
Sonatavarius
offline
Sonatavarius
1,322 posts
Farmer

"It doesn't matter where the flag flew, its what it represents. When I see that flag, I think of people fighting to keep slavery, and a bloody war."

It almost seemed like you were saying that even tho those things happened the American flag doesn't represent them. It represents peace, hope, love, joy, and better tomorrows because I say so! If we're going to look at things objectively, then maybe the Rebel flag does have a lot of garbage associated with it... but the one we fly so proudly is still piling the bodies high and can be associated with so many more negative things than the one you would look down upon. It's a case of the pot calling the kettle black... but that doesn't matter since it's so easy to say that it doesn't represent those things just b/c we say so. I'm pretty sure hate organizations like the KKK prefer to fly the Stars and Stripes and has even been centered at one point in the great hate filled southern state of Indiana (that's where at least one of our wonderful moderators is from! You and your people represent all of what's wrong in our world!). ...that was a joke btw. I see just as much hatred and racism spread over the country all over the news channels that I can honestly say it's not a southern thing. ...I actually see a lot of it other places like in California, than I do here... but that might just be by chance.

Honestly, do you really see war and hate when you see the googled picture below?

http://i261.photobucket.com/albums/ii41/shadow_wraith2007/rebel_flag_bg12.jpg

Nurvana
offline
Nurvana
2,520 posts
Farmer

but the one we fly so proudly is still piling the bodies high and can be associated with so many more negative things than the one you would look down upon


I don't think the American Flag is associated with more negative things than the Confederate Flag is. The same people (as in nation) who flew that flag over slave ships realized the wrongs of slavery and fought a war to end it. Was the war economical? Yes. Was the war political? Absolutely. Did it have nothing to do with the injustice of slavery? Not at all. The American Flag, in the long run, stands for freedom and justice. Some may disagree, sure, but you'd find a lot less people who think the Confederate Flag flies for anything honorable.
Sonatavarius
offline
Sonatavarius
1,322 posts
Farmer

As true as that might be, slavery was becoming obsolete. Maybe with the invention of new machinery the plantations would have still maintained slaves... but who wants to feed, house, clothe, and take care of one type of farm equipment when there's another that does the same or greater amount of work with steam and coal? There's always that chance that given more time the south would have had their own epiphany and stopped the practice of slavery. It's just conjecture, but racism and hatred may live on longer than it should just because we had a war and emancipation was forced. It's like a giant seed by which hatred will continue to grow.

I'm not saying I am of the opinion that all I've said is true. I'm mostly throwing bits of information out into the open because it needs to be seen and discussed.

Some of our nation's finest are in fact the world's finest... but some of them are also some of the world's worst. If you talked to some of our military men and women about all of the things they've done over there without provocation, then you'd be ashamed. I used to wonder why a lot of places out there supposedly hated us... and aside from the religious reasons and that kind of stuff I know now a little more as to why.

I think the progeny of the confederacy flying the flag has potential to show that people can change and that they can progress towards a better tomorrow without hiding their garbage. I do believe that those who participate in the southern states flag group things actively work against the KKK and try to work against racism in the here and now. I think they're called the Sons of the Confederacy or something like that... they even let a few black guys join! That's pretty honorable, right?

Maverick4
offline
Maverick4
6,800 posts
Peasant

As far as the picture goes... Dat tramp stamp tho

And there is an organization called the Sons of the Confederacy. It's largely historical in nature, and to get in you just show you had a relative fight in the war. Outside of a monthly email, it hasn't changed my life too much.

Just a thought, but one worth thinking about: Rather than seeing the flag as symbolic of something and judging the person who displays it, why not treat the flag as nothing more than a flag, and judge the person who displays it based on their own individual merits? It would be rather hypocritical, I think, to talk about reducing racism and ignorance, and then lump everyone who displays the flag as racist and ignorant. You're better off suggesting all Southerners wear cowboy hats, or that we all drive tractors.

defensestar
offline
defensestar
1 posts
Peasant

you dont??!!!?!?!?! JK. ive been to the south before, you have fast food workers too!

SSTG
offline
SSTG
13,055 posts
Treasurer

Every time I see this flag, I think about the Dukes of Hazzard TV series. They had the flag painted on top of their car (General Lee).

I'm personally not offended by it, I think it's nice. People should be offended by the action of some people, not a flag.

I like the USSR national anthem, that doesn't make me a communist and certainly NOT a fan of Putin because he still uses it.

I also like the Italian and the German anthems, thanks to Michael Schumacher when he was driving for the Ferrari F1 team.

Loop_Stratos
offline
Loop_Stratos
5,291 posts
Jester

I would go "What's that flag?"

thepyro222
offline
thepyro222
2,150 posts
Peasant

For those who don't know, the flag in question is The flag of the Southern Confederacy who seceded from the USA in the 1860's because of the threat of abolishing slavery. The fact that the South seceded caused the American civil war.

I just see the flag as a statement to the world that those people are pretending to be rednecks. The flag just means rebel.

Loop_Stratos
offline
Loop_Stratos
5,291 posts
Jester

-Lives in Southeast Asia
-Is 13 yrs old for freaking out loud
-Doesn't even try and see news

Yeah... i'll just go out of here.

231terminator
offline
231terminator
87 posts
Nomad

Well im from the south and lived here my whole life. I of course have no hate for the flag but i don't love it either. Essentially its no more than a somewhat dead symbol that some people still get fears of or hatred of. I personally don't associate it with war or hate, but with southern states in general. I understand its a pride thing but the confederacy doesn't exist anymore so it doesn't really matter

Ishtaron
offline
Ishtaron
359 posts
Blacksmith

I'm living in the South now and all of my experience with "Southern pride" and that flag are attached to phrases like, "The South will rise again!" The people who fly it say it has nothing to do with racism, but they're also the same people who advocate a return of an independent Confederacy (which only existed because Southern politicians were afraid the North would force a law through to abolish slavery), get upset at the idea of a black president, and when asked their opinion of black people will claim to not have a problem with them but don't want their daughter dating a black man. It might not specifically be a racist symbol, but there's an awful lot of racists who fly it and that's an association that's hard to shake. Especially when there's so many people like terminator that don't have any particular love for the confederate flag.

TheMostManlyMan
offline
TheMostManlyMan
5,841 posts
Chamberlain

those people are pretending to be rednecks.

As someone who lives in the south, I know that people who put that flag on their trucks etc. are 100% legit rednecks.

But I do have to agree with you in that it is more of just the redneck flag than anything.

thepyro222
offline
thepyro222
2,150 posts
Peasant

I live in Michigan and I see the flag even up here. There are obviously legit rednecks that have the confederate flag, but there are those who claim to be 'redneck' and don't really fit the bill. Don't get me wrong, Michigan has its own breed of redneck.

Showing 16-30 of 32