@Yahel007 - it isn't random, but it IS based upon stats that you cannot see. Battle power comes from so many places it is impossible to tell how upgraded his troops and heroes are.
Just because your raw battle power is higher doesn't mean his troops and heroes aren't stronger in areas that gave him a significant advantage in PVP. If you have the same battle power, but yours is the result of tower upgrades but his is because of hero levels/equipment and troop upgrades, his army will crush yours - which appears to be happening.
In addition, the mages are right next to the warriors. If his mages (or his mage hero) are stronger than yours then his will wipe your your mages and probably immediately go for your warriors - where they have a large advantage.
A better question is why you tried that matchup 3 times. After the first loss, why didn't you re-set your army so that you had a 4 type advantage setup?
I have literally never lost a 2nd fight against the same person with a 4 type advantage - at 30k battle power I've beaten people with 10k more battle power that way.
@Olinser Hey, do you know when the 'Fountain of Youth' event is ending? At present... I have 76gold cups+94gold shovels+23wood boats+26coiled ropes. My original plan was to wait for some sort of in-game notification to appear saying, "the Fountain of Youth Event is ending in 5days! Use all your Event items now!". But, seeing how such a notification taking place is seeming to be increasingly unlikely... what should I do?
(You can take a look at my Event status here: http://my.jetscreenshot.com/23333/20141025-aa3t-1242kb )
@Olinser Also, what else do you recommend upgrading with the Black Soul Crystals? I've currently spent Black Soul Crystals to acquire: 1)Jungle Warfare Tower; 2)Dragoneer Tower; and 3)Sniper Tower. And, as per your advice, I've also bought '.50Cal Upgrade' for the Sniper Tower. I also bought the 'Royal Guard' spell-upgrade and the 'Slowing-Blizzard' spell-upgrade. They're definitely doing the trick-- I even managed to get 3stars on Fauna Forge Heroic! So what else do you recommend?
@mercwithmouth ... uhm, it already has ended, for purposes of unlocking chalices for tier rewards. All 5 rounds are over. Timers for the rounds were located in the 'Rewards' page, which has a button on the 'Rank' tab in the event.
For upgrades... that's kind of up to you. I upgraded the Sniper 0.50 cal ability, then unlocked Blizzard, then went back and unlocked one of the Canoneer abilities.
After that it's kind of a crapshoot, nothing is really that fantastic. I'll probably use mine further upgrading the spells because that keeps increasing hte damage per level on them.
@Olinser Come to think of it... The upgrades for the magic-spells increase the damage-potential, while also giving more abilities. All the while not having an additional 'during-the-match' cost to utilize unlike the 'dark-soul-crystal' upgrades for towers which do invariably entail an additional 'during-the-match' cost to utilize. I'll also mention that the 'Immoral Militamen' upgrade are supposed to be able to attack Flying Enemies. Even so... which tower-upgrade did you use for your mage-tower?
I haven't bought an upgrade for the mage tower. Except for the single level that literally FORCES you to use the mage tower because it is the only one available, there is pretty much never a reason to build a mage tower ever.
sorry for my bad english: - In the tavern after knocking archer predictable drop in the form of a boat and a couple of potions - Dark soul only in PVP, although the all upgrade is tied to them - Drop the boss is funny - Pass the card without extra features on the map 3 is very difficult, until you open a couple of upgrades level towers, and that's where the boss - there's just not enough money for upgrade towers of kills monsters - Aladdin's shop is not working, the rank is not considered, the counter discovery does not work, bonuses for opening not charged - Sometimes after avto-battle not all drop comes to inventory