ForumsWEPRAnswer the Ultimate Question

124 19067
Aquajag
offline
Aquajag
89 posts
Nomad

This is more Philosophy than strictly Religion, but still, here's the Ultimate Question:

Why?

  • 124 Replies
razzmonk
offline
razzmonk
496 posts
Nomad

Why what!?

Zophia
offline
Zophia
9,434 posts
Scribe

Because of the topic title I keep thinking 42...

But, ehm... Because?

Zophia
offline
Zophia
9,434 posts
Scribe

Okay, stop going 'Why what?'
'Why?' is the ultimate question, because you can keep on asking it... There is no perfectly finite answer, no matter what you're discussing... There is always another Why?

Drace
offline
Drace
3,880 posts
Nomad

Why?[i]

Aquajag
offline
Aquajag
89 posts
Nomad

Why what!?

What not why? Why everything! WHY?
Owen135731
offline
Owen135731
2,128 posts
Peasant

the true answer to that question, is why not?

RathRaid
offline
RathRaid
129 posts
Nomad

Why is just humans trying to fulfill they're need for knowledge. Why is the ultimate question, yes, but of course, just touching on religion a bit, many could say that the answer to "why" is always "God". However, getting off religion, some people might just say the answer to most "Whys" is "fate". Of course, there is always the question of "Why is fate the answer to "Why"", which would literally prbly kill me, becuase my brain is seriously not capable of that... WHY?!

Aquajag
offline
Aquajag
89 posts
Nomad

But, ehm... Because?


Why because? (Bet you saw that coming. Very popular question when I was a kid)

the true answer to that question, is why not?

True. It could be an answer, simply because it is just as equally unanswerable as the previous question. So it serves as an answer insofar as it becomes the new primary question, thus derailing the original questioner and turning her or him into the answerer.
arkaninerenegade
offline
arkaninerenegade
785 posts
Nomad

does it have an answer

Drace
offline
Drace
3,880 posts
Nomad

This is not philosophy, its just an uncompleted statement posing as one. I suppose it seems to be doing its job because it gets everyone confused.

"Why" says nothing, nor does "Why everything". Why does everything exist is a question, or even why is everything purple, but 'why' alone is just a word.

You need to be specified...Why what?

Drace
offline
Drace
3,880 posts
Nomad

But if you want to keep making a little game out of posting nonsense then I ask you,

why why?

trigger347
offline
trigger347
33 posts
Peasant

To ask that kind of question implies that there is an answer. Moreover, if there is an answer, it is known in ways and forms that can be conceptualized, formed and presented. Therefore, to ask the question is itself troubled because any answer to the question has not only a different meaning to both the one asking the question and the one answering it, but that the question itself is infinite and can never be answered.


Perhaps the best summation is presented in the movie Dogma where the distant relative of jesus prevents the fallen angels from being forgiven and she asks god, in essence, "why". God responds by smiling and touching God's finger to her nose and making honking noise.

kris1027
offline
kris1027
506 posts
Nomad

Perhaps the answer is simply unfathomable.

GreatZulu638
offline
GreatZulu638
279 posts
Nomad

why? because of the curious nature of humans.. it drives us to want to know answers, to toy with things to see how they work, to break things so we can try to fix them... and also 42..

Agent_86
offline
Agent_86
2,132 posts
Nomad

Well, the answer is above all our finite minds. No matter how much we try to solve it, it will always be over our heads...

There is no real answer that we can understand...

Here's a quote from a great book:

"In the beginning God..."
Genesis 1:1a

There's your answer.

Showing 1-15 of 124