ForumsThe TavernComment Feedback

126 20675
sense
offline
sense
1,035 posts
Nomad

This thread, will be a way to promote your merit-worthy comments, to us all...

Some of you might say: 'Shouldn't this be in the Flash Games section?'
well you are probably right, but this is a little less involved with games, and a little more involved in help.

Also, if you have any issues with writing merits, you can give it a shot, and ask for feedback. Experienced, but not quite right? Get your feedback here!

To all mods, this is not something that you have to look at, to see the comments, this was designed for people to say 'Hey, have a look at this comment. Do you like it?' and 'Could you tell me what I need to improve on?'

  • 126 Replies
knight_34
offline
knight_34
13,817 posts
Farmer

This seems to be a good idea. Especially if you want people to see your comments. Good merit worthy comments easily get buried by short comments and spam. Thus, the comments which were made with effort are invisible.

Pazx
offline
Pazx
5,842 posts
Peasant

Good idea man, but I'm sure some jerk will turn this thread into a 'lz upvote my commnt i want a merit' thread.

Yeah...

Good comments often die...

mason1
offline
mason1
202 posts
Nomad

not bad.. it's a good idea for people that are worthy

sense
offline
sense
1,035 posts
Nomad

Thanks for the support...

If anyone does really spam, then I will tell a mod, to please warn him, the idea that people won't spam is required for this thread to work.

knight_34
offline
knight_34
13,817 posts
Farmer

Someone now should (if they have any) post comments that they think are worthy to receive a merit. They should also provide us a link to that game so we can vote up if we want to.

miguelin11
offline
miguelin11
2,905 posts
Nomad

So this is the place Mods can(if they want) look for merit-worthy comments or is it just for users to vote up comments?

still this's kinda a good idea

Peter213
offline
Peter213
190 posts
Nomad

Hello.

I just made a review on Castle clout.

Do I need to improve anything?

Castle clout



Review by Peter213
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The game play is good, the game lags a bit. The quality is decent, but not the best I've seen tough.
The music is nice, a bit repetitive tough.
The sounds are great, the controls are a bit confusing like, the way you throw the rock, sometimes it's a little hard to throw it.
A nice tip I can give you (Game creator) is to make more levels and a better graphics.

None the less this game deserves a 9/10.

Bye >>Peter213<<

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

>>Peter213<<

miguelin11
offline
miguelin11
2,905 posts
Nomad

grammar and spelling error from your review peter213

tough

tough.

None the less

a better graphics.
Peter213
offline
Peter213
190 posts
Nomad

What?

My spell check said that there were no spelling errors.

Darn you to hell spell check!!!

Those are the little things that I sometimes don't see.

-_- Crappy spell check.

Thank you miguelin

knight_34
offline
knight_34
13,817 posts
Farmer

I must.. um.. contribute to this thread.

Knight_34's Feudalism Review.

My comment can be found somewhere around here

If you find my comment there will be two of them. This was caused due to browser problems. If you are going to vote up for it, vote up the one with the larger text.

Ahhh... Feudalism II. I remember playing the first installment. That was about thirteen months ago, brings back memories. Anyway, I will now get straight to the point.

Feudalism II is a great game and I'd surely recommend it to anyone who likes strategy or RPGs.

Graphics - The graphics of Feudalism II are not perfect, but do look great indeed. Doesn't really need improvement but will definitely look better if they had more detail. 8.5/10 Great graphics.

Sound - If I were to pick the least developed out of the aspects of the game, I would pick sound. First of all, there is no music and secondly there are few sound effects. The game would definitely feel more satisfactory with more sound.
8/10 - Average sound.

Gameplay - The game plays well, you choose one of the six varied factions and embark on a military campaign. Battles are violent and intense, with heads flying around, lots of noise and many dead bodies strewn around. If I were to compare the original with this sequel, I would rather refer to this as not a sequel but as more of a improved, expanded Feudalism. The sequel has more weapons and armor than the original had, more factions, soldiers and characters to choose from and completely new features such as, duels, weapon upgrades, runes and a whole lot of stuff. Despite all of these changes the game still has the original characters, weapons, nations even some of the original towns. Not that it is a bad thing. The game is more even and balanced than the first with bugs and glitches fixed. Even simple suggestions like the sell all feature which I had asked for way back were implemented. Now there are even difficulty options to choose from. Excellent gameplay 10/10

Replay -

If there are countless items to choose from, six factions, twelve characters, many soldiers to choose from and all of those other things to numerous to count, then I think that the replay value is great. Great Replay Value 9.5/10

Pros -

Good Graphics
Excellent Gameplay
Great Replay Value

Cons:

Somewhat lacking in music and sound.

9/10 Superb game!
(One of the best of my favorite flash games!)

Peter213
offline
Peter213
190 posts
Nomad

A nice review Knight_34.

You should earn a merit for it.

>>Peter213<<

knight_34
offline
knight_34
13,817 posts
Farmer

A nice review Knight_34.

You should earn a merit for it.

>>Peter213<<


Your compliment is much appreciated. You got anymore comments. I do have one more that I remember. I guess the other comments I have written have slipped out of my mind.
sense
offline
sense
1,035 posts
Nomad

Peter213, I have a few things to say about your comment...

It wasn't long enough, nor in much detail. That is a really important point.

Some grammar issues. This means that it is less appealing for mods.

It's to late for me, and I better go to bed, but that is the best I can do now.

Peter213
offline
Peter213
190 posts
Nomad

Hm.. ok I'll work on my reviews.

Keep in mind that this is my first review.

Pazx
offline
Pazx
5,842 posts
Peasant

You both made two big errors.

One: Length

Two: NEVER state the section you are judging. Mods don't like comments that are;

Music: etc

Gameplay: W/e

Controls:

Graphics:

I just think iit makes the message look less professional....

Now it's late at night and i've made so many typos its not funny. Goodniight.

Showing 1-15 of 126