ForumsPopular MediaMegadeth or Metallica?

59 9127
BioWeapon117
offline
BioWeapon117
62 posts
Nomad

The Megadeth vs Metallica thing has been going on since Dave Mustaine was kicked out of Metallica and Megadeth rose up to challenge Metallica. Which band do you prefer? What are you favorite albums and songs?

  • 59 Replies
hitmanvp95
offline
hitmanvp95
1,089 posts
Nomad

lol that doesnt mean im dumb. metallica jsut doesnt write good lyrics. i mean i know what alot of there songs mean.

ride the lighting is about getting exectued
one is about a fallen war veteran
blackened is about what we are doing to our world.

they do have straight foward meanings alot of the time, but they evolved.

kill'em all.... was about nothing lol WHIPLASH!!! DOES NOT HAVE MEANING!!!!

as theyre albums have grown into more poetic lyrics over time. while megadeth have always been good at writing storys in there songs


Sure, the lyrics on Kill'em All are bad, but how come you think Metallica's lyrics are bad? How come this be bad:

New blood joins this earth
And quickly he's subdued
Through constant pained disgrace
The young boy learns their rules

With time the child draws in
This whipping boy done wrong
Deprived of all his thoughts
The young man struggles on and on he's known
A vow unto his own
That never from this day
His will they'll take away-eay


Or this:
End of passion play, crumbling away
I'm your source of self-destruction
Veins that pump with fear, sucking darkest clear
Leading on your deaths construction
Taste me you will see
More is all you need
Dedicated to
How I'm killing you


Not mention many others. Sorry man, you may not like Metallica but saying their lyrics are bad is just stupid.
hitmanvp95
offline
hitmanvp95
1,089 posts
Nomad

Oh, snap... James Hetfield has really changed his look <.<

BTW I love The Unforgiven and Master of Puppets


Yeah, he's changed a lot since the early days.

And yes, The Unforgiven and Master of Puppets are two of Metallica's best songs.
hateful94
offline
hateful94
2 posts
Nomad

Metallica all the way!
Album: Load
Song: Fuel

BioWeapon117
offline
BioWeapon117
62 posts
Nomad

fuel always gets me pumped

doules
offline
doules
16 posts
Nomad

MEGADETH ALL THE WAY

thepossum
offline
thepossum
3,035 posts
Nomad

I'm going to go with Metallica. I just find Metallica to be way better. No offense doules. =P

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

not like Metallica


i love metallica how dare you lol. i just like megadeth a little more.
snipershot325
offline
snipershot325
844 posts
Nomad

definetly metallica!!!!

freakymonkey
offline
freakymonkey
290 posts
Nomad

this is such a dumb thread cuz obviously everyone WILL say metallica their music is amazing

Motorheadbanger
offline
Motorheadbanger
279 posts
Nomad

Megadeth is way better than Metallica not only for consistency, but because Megadeth's overall musicianship is much better. Also Dave wrote about half of Kill em All, and two songs on Ride the Lightning. Not trying to go off topic, but Kirk Hammett not only took the Four Horsemen from Mustaine, he also took a song(Trapped Under Ice) riffs and solos from Gary Holt when Kirk was in Exodus.

AlphaPhatMike
offline
AlphaPhatMike
12 posts
Nomad

I think Metallica is better. Think about it, Dave Mustaine was released from Metallica for being a crappy band member. If he would've never screwed up, Megadeth wouldn't exist. So Megadeth is kind of like an accident. Metallica has more legacy, and is more thrash. Metallica is the greatest band of all time. No argument.

Motorheadbanger
offline
Motorheadbanger
279 posts
Nomad

Metallica is not more thrash than Megadeth. I'll admit Kill em All, And Justice for All and Ride the Lightning are good, but Killing is My Buisness, Peace Sells,So Far So Good So What and Rust in Peace are much better. Also Dave may have been a screwed up alcoholic (now sober) band member but he is a much better guitarist than James and Kirk. James couldn't even play guitar when Metallica first formed. Megadeth may have been an accident but there much better than Metallica. One more thing Master of Puppets is the most overrated album and there not they are not the greatest band ever.

Snake211
offline
Snake211
234 posts
Nomad

i love metallica.

SpyreWorks
offline
SpyreWorks
172 posts
Nomad

I think Metallica is better. Think about it, Dave Mustaine was released from Metallica for being a crappy band member. If he would've never screwed up, Megadeth wouldn't exist. So Megadeth is kind of like an accident. Metallica has more legacy, and is more thrash. Metallica is the greatest band of all time. No argument.


This is the stupidest comment I've ever read in my life.

Think about it, Dave Mustaine was released from Metallica for being a crappy band member. If he would've never screwed up, Megadeth wouldn't exist.


He was kicked out because he was a drug addict and mean person, not because he couldn't play guitar.

Metallica has more legacy, and is more thrash.


Metallica is more thrash? HAH! Compare KIMB, Endgame, Rust in Peace, SFSGSW or basically any other Megadeth album to ANYTHING Metallica have ever done -- Megadeth has always been thrash metal (except for a short lapse in the late 90s), while Metallica was becoming less thrashy from the moment it was born

Metallica is the greatest band of all time. No argument.


Yes, there is an argument, but I won't go there.
Motorheadbanger
offline
Motorheadbanger
279 posts
Nomad

Thank you SpyreWorks Metallica fan boys make me angry.

Showing 31-45 of 59