Forums → WEPR → Abortion: Right or Wrong?

Nobody thinks aborting is the RIGHT thing to do. It's more of a question about the circumstances and if it's ok or not.

Hello again, mdv96

Answer this, fellow forum posters, if you would please: ok
Is it ok
Morally
Lawfullyy,
Other (Allowed via government permission)
I mean government permission because if aborting was illegal, the following situation may happen: A man has kidney failure, and needs a transplant. He and his wife both share a relatively rare blood type. No one kidney is availible, and there is no time to helicopter one over from another hospital. However, the wife is pregnant. If the wife donated her kidney, she would have to abort the baby. It would not survive. What would happen in this scenerio? Please tell me

Nobody thinks aborting is the RIGHT thing to do. It's more of a question about the circumstances and if it's ok or not.

And have you seen how crowded the adoption centres are? Abortion is a much kinder option.

(barely controls laughter)I think he meant too many people are getting abortions???? I have no idea, Nurvana

DoctorHouse, the dad would die. Catholic doctrine says the only valid reason to abort is to save the mother.

thank you for your input, Nurvana. But I am talking about government law, not religion law. Still, I appriciate what you had to say, for I had no idea

Catholic doctrine says the only valid reason to abort is to save the mother.

Yes, but I believe he was saying the religious boundaries should be put into consideration, which they should.

if the family is religious, of course, but if the family is not religious, should they be forced to follow the doctrine of a faith that is not their own.

of course not, unless that was the law

*government law

if the family is religious, of course, but if the family is not religious, should they be forced to follow the doctrine of a faith that is not their own.

ah. I see your point. If a religion says you can abort, but the goverment law in your area says you cannot, what would happen?

ah. I see your point. If a religion says you can abort, but the goverment law in your area says you cannot, what would happen?