Damascus attacks with the sword(it's a Merciful sword, so it can deal nonlethal damage whenever he wants it to). Rolled a 15. He would have hit either way, although with the fists it would have been a close call. "Pay up!"
Actually, if he used his fists he would miss. I forgot about his +1 for Dodge. Actually, I also forgot about Combat Expertise. That would be a total of 37. Wait, 31<37. Should we take a step back and have it miss or just move on?