Forums → The Tavern → [necro] Who Wins? Pie vs Cake

Meat pie of course. Game over man, GAME OVER

I'm pretty sure cheesecake is a cake. But I love apple pie and pumpkin pie. I also like ice cream cake. So I guess it's a tie for me.

lemon merange pie! best ever,also like idontsuckthatmuch said,i like cheesecake

so what i ment is its a tie with me

unfortunately i never had pie... but from what i read about it i think i like cake better

uhm... depends on the flavor.

chocolate cake vs chocolate pie.

Chocolate pie

lemon cake or lemon merange pie.

lemon cake.

Pies are more versatile than cakes. There's a wide range of sweet or savory fillings I can enjoy. Cakes, well I love them too but..

Pies.

As said before it all depends on the flavor. I love chocolate pecan pie, but hate pumpkin, apple, and any other fruit pies. Whether or not I like cake all depends on the frosting. I can handle all types of cake, but some frostings are gross, like the cream cheese based one. Also, it matters which frosting goes with which cake. White on white is gross, but yellow cake with chocolate frosting is da bomb.

So my vote goes to cake.

Pumpkin pie is my favorite kind of pie, it's not too sweet but the filling is soft and chewy, just delicious.

I can't eat cake often because of how sweet the cake is and with all that frosting it makes me sick.

I choose pie.

It would have to be pie,

Reason:

You Can't Put Fondant Frosting (YUCK) on pies


Pies!

[quote=thebluerabbit]unfortunately i never had pie... [/quote]
What the... Wow, that's... Unusual.

Pie ftw. Cake is usually soo sugary for me to eat. Makes me sick, like Matrix.

its a tie for me because well pie is epic and i love ice cream cake
and what about cupcakes those are like mini cakes right?

That's like asking to choose which one of your kids you like more.

I think that is a difficult question to answer because they are both delicious. I would say that it depends on the flavor of each one but I would choose a cake instead of pie.

pie people are scary people!!! and thats why i pick pie... pie wins. nothing beats pie. chuck norris made pie. end of discussion.