ForumsWEPREvolution

779 182545
stormwolf722
offline
stormwolf722
227 posts
Nomad

Well a lot of people have been telling me evolution is real. They give me the most craziest surreal 'facts'. Has anyone discovered any fish with legs? Any humans with gills or fins? If you put all the pieces of a watch into you're pocket and shake it around for trillions of years, will it ever become a watch? Is there but one possibility? Or if you completely dismantle a chicken and a fish, and put it into a box, shaking it around for trillions of years. Will it ever become a fish with wings? or a chicken with fins? :l

  • 779 Replies
nichodemus
offline
nichodemus
14,991 posts
Grand Duke

Yeah because it's so much better to think you were made out of dirt instead of being an evolved monkey....


Or the rib of a man, just to entertain him.
partydevil
offline
partydevil
5,129 posts
Jester

ive seen you guys talking about something being perfect.
i believe the perfect does not exist.

if something is perfect then it has no flaws and is unable to improof itself.
well some cristians say that god is perfect. they also say that humans are a "copy" of god (sorry can't remember the line they use for it right now)
if that is true then how come that all humans are not perfect?
how come that out immune system fails about 2-3 times a year?
how come that we argue about what is best for us all?
if god is perfect then why did he create the apple for eve.
if god knows evrything why didn't he plant the tree miles away from eve so she would never be able to eat or even find it.

all of this is not perfect. so god also couldn't be able to create a perfect world.
if he was then it means that he also made perfect humans. wich is clearly is not the case. or are humans no longer part of this world?

btw young earth creationists usualy do not read anything unless it's religion based. it doesn't matter how much proof we can give them. they just ignore it. end of story.

nichodemus
offline
nichodemus
14,991 posts
Grand Duke

a "copy" of god (sorry can't remember the line they use for it right now)


God made Man in His image.

I believe that was the line you were looking for?
partydevil
offline
partydevil
5,129 posts
Jester

ah yea thx for that nicho =)

Reiki000
offline
Reiki000
232 posts
Nomad

well some cristians say

what about muslims?

Greetings
Reiki000
offline
Reiki000
232 posts
Nomad

I bet you've heard this question before, but I wonder your answers.

Can genetic mutations produce positive changes? Can you give any example?

Greetings

partydevil
offline
partydevil
5,129 posts
Jester

i was leaving muslims out and didn't say creationists because i dunno if your book also says that man is made in gods image. or if the god is considered perfect.

if so then i should have said creationists.

nichodemus
offline
nichodemus
14,991 posts
Grand Duke

Can genetic mutations produce positive changes? Can you give any example?


Easy. Your eyeballs which are looking at the screen now.
Kasic
offline
Kasic
5,552 posts
Jester

Can genetic mutations produce positive changes? Can you give any example?


All positive changes have been mutations, so, everything beneficial to us counts into this category.

A mutation isn't necessarily good or bad, it's just an unplanned change. As defined...

1: a significant and basic alteration : change
2: umlaut
3a : a relatively permanent change in hereditary material involving either a physical change in chromosome relations or a biochemical change in the codons that make up genes; also : the process of producing a mutation

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/mutation

Notice that none of which specify whether it is good or bad, it's jut a change.
b : an individual, strain, or trait resulting from mutation
Reiki000
offline
Reiki000
232 posts
Nomad

i was leaving muslims out and didn't say creationists because i dunno if your book also says that man is made in gods image. or if the god is considered perfect.

Man can't even imagine how God looks like, let stand that we are created to His image, is what we believe. And, we consider that God is Almighty and Perfect.

Easy. Your eyeballs which are looking at the screen now.

Could you explain please?

All positive changes have been mutations, so, everything beneficial to us counts into this category.

So, every change is a mutation?

A mutation isn't necessarily good or bad, it's just an unplanned change. As defined...

As far as I know/knew were mutations neutral, or negative. I think that we could call a positive mutation an advantageous mutation, right? Because an unplanned change can't be positive, right?

Greetings
HahiHa
online
HahiHa
8,256 posts
Regent

So, every change is a mutation?

No, changes are mostly selected genetic variations, not mutations. A shift in the gene pool if you want.

On the 'god made man in his image' thing.. either that is to be taken literally.. in this case it doesn't mean that we are a perfect copy of him, or else how would you explain males/females? But even then that would mean that god at least looks like a bipedal cripple like we are :P. Or you don't take it literally and then I really don't see what sense it could possibly make.
master565
offline
master565
4,104 posts
Nomad

If you want a much more obvious change that is detectable right away, rather than over thousands of yeas, here you go.

Could you explain please?


First, organisms had no eyes. Eventually, a mutation caused an organism to develop light sensitive cells, but the image they would have received was terrible. As these kept mutating over thousands of years, they got more and more accurate, giving sharper and more colored images, until the point that we have the eyes that we have today.
partydevil
offline
partydevil
5,129 posts
Jester

Man can't even imagine how God looks like, let stand that we are created to His image, is what we believe.


that means that god intended to make humans imperfect?

we consider that God is Almighty and Perfect.

do muslims believe that this perfect, almight (all knowing i guess.) (and all loving also?) god created a perfect world?
partydevil
offline
partydevil
5,129 posts
Jester

an unplanned change can't be positive, right?


and why not actualy?

when you win the lottery, then that will make a unplanned change on your bank accaunt. a positive change.
Reiki000
offline
Reiki000
232 posts
Nomad

you want a much more obvious change that is detectable right away, rather than over thousands of yeas, here you go.

Any other example? Because, if such mutations, that are detectable now, are on an higher level, or if this happens many times, then I can be satisfied with mutations. But if such things happen, just a few time, then it's something happening rarely.

Out of that, why did this happen just with this baby, and not by anybody else? There is a group of believers that commit circumcision for 4000 years. Why don't they have any children with a child that already is "circumcised"? Or muslims. We are commiting circumcision for 1400 years. Why is there no muslim child that already is "circumcised"? Is something like that happening rarely?

First, organisms had no eyes. Eventually, a mutation caused an organism to develop light sensitive cells, but the image they would have received was terrible. As these kept mutating over thousands of years, they got more and more accurate, giving sharper and more colored images, until the point that we have the eyes that we have today.

Why did the evolution of the eye take so less time? And how did complex organisms evolve?

Greetings
Showing 316-330 of 779