ForumsPopular Mediawho likes the movies of books or the book instead of the movie?

18 6367
derp3101
offline
derp3101
171 posts
Peasant

It really depends on the book we're talking about.Harry Potter=great movie,even better books.Stars wars=awesome movies,books?

  • 18 Replies
Kasic
offline
Kasic
5,552 posts
Jester

I have never seen a movie which I thought was better than the book. This is for several reasons.

1) Movies always leave out events or get things wrong.

2) Movies always rely on the acting ability of the actors, while in books you get to make it sound exactly how it should.

3) I can imagine much better scenery and effects than I've yet to see in movies.

4) Books are far more in depth.

daleks
offline
daleks
3,766 posts
Chamberlain

Honestly it depends which came first. If it was a book first then 99% of the time the book will be better. If it was a movie that was made into a book then the movie was probably better.

KhaoticSniper
offline
KhaoticSniper
210 posts
Nomad

I have never seen a movie which I thought was better than the book. This is for several reasons.



Agreed!!!!
Santi_
offline
Santi_
1,900 posts
Nomad

Whenever you have an oppurtunity a book you've read turn into a movie, the scenes depicted often do not match with the imagery created when reading the book. This allows you to have a connection to the book, and make you feel as if you were there when you're reading it. The movie has everything laid out, and often does not include the major details because of directors/writers wanting the viewers not to be "forced" to watch a stretched scene. Which may be one of the reasons said book is popular, and has sold enough to qualify to become a movie in the first place.

TheMostManlyMan
offline
TheMostManlyMan
5,843 posts
Chamberlain

it depends and this shouldn't be in this forum if i'm correct

EmperorPalpatine
offline
EmperorPalpatine
9,439 posts
Jester

Jaws was probably the only one where I liked the movie a bit better. The character development was great. In the book they returned to shore every night. The isolation factor in the movie made it more intense. I don't want to spoil anything, but in my opinion the movie's ending was better.

omarzocco
offline
omarzocco
280 posts
Nomad

Well the books are always more interesting to me like Harry Potter the movies aren't as good as the books wich is disappointing and even the 2 movies for the 7nth wasn't as good but better I guess...

Rapyion
offline
Rapyion
2,300 posts
Shepherd

Well, in theory, movies have less description than books. In the book, everything there is imagined perfectly. In the movies, some things will go wrong. Theory, anyway. I don't watch movies when I've already read the books.

Masterforger
offline
Masterforger
1,824 posts
Peasant

Book, duh. I've never read a book that was worse then the movie that came after it.

thepyro222
offline
thepyro222
2,150 posts
Peasant

The only movie based from a book I would consider as good as said book would be Lord of the Rings. Simply because Peter Jackson pretty much stayed as close as he could to the book, the acting was stellar, and Tolkein's writing, if you've ever read it, is somewhat difficult to understand.

SSTG
offline
SSTG
13,055 posts
Treasurer

I read Planet of the Apes by Pierre Boule and I saw the 1960's movie.
I liked the movie better.
I saw the movies 2001 and 2010 and I liked them but I only read 2060 and 3001. If someone read them can you tell me which were best?
I'll have to read them some day.

TheGr8est
offline
TheGr8est
703 posts
Nomad

In my opinion, books are better because their more in-depth and are just usually more captivating, and thats why I sometimes read books.
But movies are more relaxing and give you a better picture of the basic ideas (not the details though).

sasukemystery
offline
sasukemystery
1,447 posts
Nomad

I like to read the book first because it is pretty original because in the Percy Jackson series Annabeth's hair was blonde but in the movie it was brownish.

NoStradamys
offline
NoStradamys
7 posts
Farmer

Books mainly >_<

avenger671
offline
avenger671
63 posts
Nomad

Books are usually better. Unless they are really old movies, then the books are boring and the movies are OK.

Showing 1-15 of 18