ForumsWEPR[nec]Christianity vs Atheism

3094 567470
kiddslayer12
offline
kiddslayer12
70 posts
Nomad

I am a christian, i and i strongly belive in my lord jesus christ, and i also belive that if you belive in him and except him as your savior, u will go to heaven. and i also believe that he created the world, not the big bang, or that we came from stupid apes.

  • 3,094 Replies
MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

I have no doubt that logical and intelligent theists exist Samy. My issue is when people claim to have a logical explanation for their belief and then go on to use irrational, illogical, and fallacious arguments to prove their point and then become upset when they are informed of their errors.

However if you are truly logical you will have to look at your holy text with great criticism and scrutiny. Applying the rules of logic to religious text tends to disprove their arguments, and as texts are the basis of most religions, it tends to bring the religion itself under question as to it's validity.

samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

I have no doubt that logical and intelligent theists exist Samy. My issue is when people claim to have a logical explanation for their belief and then go on to use irrational, illogical, and fallacious arguments to prove their point and then become upset when they are informed of their errors.


Well while I can't say my core belief is logically I can say I can logically defend many points of my belief (if not the explicit belief in God.)

However if you are truly logical you will have to look at your holy text with great criticism and scrutiny. Applying the rules of logic to religious text tends to disprove their arguments, and as texts are the basis of most religions, it tends to bring the religion itself under question as to it's validity.


Here I tend to disagree; while it does create questions I believe that if you search long enough you can find the answer in said religious text.
MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

Here I tend to disagree; while it does create questions I believe that if you search long enough you can find the answer in said religious text.


This is like saying you can find the answer from a psychic. If you search long enough you will find some vague passage that can be interpreted to mean anything you want it to. This is not a definitive clear cut answer.
samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

This is like saying you can find the answer from a psychic. If you search long enough you will find some vague passage that can be interpreted to mean anything you want it to. This is not a definitive clear cut answer.


Once again I disagree but this is about as easy to argue as the existence of God; so.
MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

Have you heard of one thought by a brilliant guy? "If I believe in God, I will be saved, or nothing will happen. If I wouldn't believe in God, I have a chance to either die in hell, or that nothing will happen." I think I would rather believe in God. Why go against him?


It's a false dichotomy, since there are numerous religions and denominations of those religions.

I like to think that I would be an athiest but my parents had me go to a christian church as a child.


Why would that stop you from being an atheist?

Drinking in moderation is fine getting drunk is okay becoming an alcoholic is not;why, because you're putting alcohol above God.


There's more to it then that when it comes to addiction.
I've know alcoholics who still faithfully followed God just as much as the next Christian. Perhaps even more so then you. They would often pray for God to help them with their addiction. I'll let you take a guess how well that worked.

I forgot you guys don't know me well enough to understand my views on most things. Sorry. I think there should be different colours. Blue text usually indicates sarcasm.


Around here that means your a Mod.

all atheists need to learn how to believe and hang on to some hope


I'm fully capable of believing in something, I just want some evidence first. I also hope for things all the time.

who knows where Atheist might end up.


We get ham sandwiches...(sorry running joke)

If you believe there is no God then explain to me how everything came to be? And if you say the big bang then how did the gases or particles get there to make the planets and stars, etc?


Again matter/energy can't be created or destroyed just changed. How the singularity got there it may have always been (time holding no meaning here since there was no space). Another possibilities is that all the matter/energy budded off from another universe.
Currently we just don't know.

No answers to those questions is why I believe in God.


Saying "I don't know" doesn't mean we should automatically say "God dud it". Why is it when ever something can't be currently explained a theist says it was magic?

I mean how else did we got on the perfect planet for life?


Well if this planet wasn't suited for life we wouldn't be here to ask why we are here. It's a bit like asking how a chocolate bunny fits the mold it came out of.

God simply is he always was and he always will be.


"If we say God always existed, then why not save a step and say the universe always existed" -Carl Sagan

Though given the laws of physics I think he would have been more accurate to say matter/energy.

Alt is constantly harping about the primeval atom that caused time to come into existence at the same time as matter because the two depend on each other for existence. God, somehow, ties into that being the being that is after time started. Remember something has to be uncreated.


It's not so much something being uncreated as it is changing from one form to another. Exactly at what point was God needed for this process?

When coming up with a solution you want to start with the most simplified answer and work your way up adding new variables as the evidence for them is presented. Adding God is only adding not only adds an unnecessary variable, but no evidence for it has been presented giving no reason to add it.

Well while I can't say my core belief is logically I can say I can logically defend many points of my belief (if not the explicit belief in God.)


I think your one of the smarter theists on here but when you argue religion your use of logic often goes out the window in favor of assertions.

Once again I disagree but this is about as easy to argue as the existence of God; so.


he has a point. Scripture has been interpreted and reinterpreted in numerous ways. This is something that is clearly not clear cut. Far to often as we have seen on the forum, many things in the Bible have to be given an apologetic treatment in order to make any kind of sense at all.
Besides using the Bible to justify the Bible is a fallacy in it self.
Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

[/quote]We get ham sandwiches



Lucky...
God simply is he always was and he always will be.


You sure got him...
When coming up with a solution you want to start with the most simplified answer and work your way up adding new variables as the evidence for them is presented. Adding God is only adding not only adds an unnecessary variable, but no evidence for it has been presented giving no reason to add it


That's completely from an atheist standpoint however; if you're a theist you cannot consider God to be an "unnecessary value", but as some could see a completely necessary one, considering
Another possibilities is that all the matter/energy budded off from another universe.
Currently we just don't know.[quote]
Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

Um okay switch the quotes and the non quotes *FACEPALM*

Anonym0us
offline
Anonym0us
81 posts
Nomad

can anyone disprove god?
no?
case closed.

314d1
offline
314d1
3,817 posts
Nomad

can anyone disprove god?
no?
case closed.


http://static.rcgroups.com/forums/attachments/2/7/7/9/3/9/a2926156-219-Facepalm%20jesus-facepalm-facepalm.jpg

Can you disprove I have an Orc camp in my backyard? No? Case closed. I have an orc camp in my backyard.
Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

can anyone disprove god?
no?
case closed.


People could say the lack of evidence supporting Him can disprove God by itself.
Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

Can you disprove I have an Orc camp in my backyard? No? Case closed. I have an orc camp in my backyard.


Well, true, he cannot. However, he is not rapidly creating threads trying to disprove the orcs in your backyard, as you are doing with God.
314d1
offline
314d1
3,817 posts
Nomad

Well, true, he cannot. However, he is not rapidly creating threads trying to disprove the orcs in your backyard, as you are doing with God.



Then stop trying to disprove the orcs and disprove there physical effect. If you were to go into my backyard you would be able to prove that there were no orc footprints, smell, or sight of orc. That is what we are trying to do with god, disprove the physical things.
Avorne
offline
Avorne
3,085 posts
Nomad

I think I should point out that the burden of proof is on the one asserting the claim - AKA religious people.

Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

Then stop trying to disprove the orcs and disprove there physical effect. If you were to go into my backyard you would be able to prove that there were no orc footprints, smell, or sight of orc. That is what we are trying to do with god, disprove the physical things.


when exactly did we try and disprove the orcs? Hey if you got into heaven, you'd see God so I really don't see where this Orc thing is going
Anonym0us
offline
Anonym0us
81 posts
Nomad

314d1, orcs are imagined up by humans within the 20th century.

where as god COULD have or COULD NOT have been imagined up by humans a couple thousand years ago. nobody knows. your logic is full of holes.

and failed troll is failed. gg

Showing 1726-1740 of 3094