"human" =/= "humane"
So when Fish says, "humanity is the quality of being human", I believe he means the quality of being a human being, which is a status; being humane is a matter of acting.
"human" should be "humane"
"
being humane is a matter of acting."
I think being humane is a matter of feeling but in other way you are also correct because some of the people show other that they are humane but in real they are not.
f it doesn't work in reality, it can't apply to reality. Therefore, it is irrelevant.
I said only think (imagine) but you are taking it as in real life.
That example doesn't work with the premise that you gave. You said that God knows everything. You also said that God created everything. Everything includes the devil. BUT because the devil happens to be God's enemy, you conclude that God is not to blame even though He knowingly caused it all.
If you see past the religious doublethink, the problem with this belief system is quite clear.
I said imaginary and creative example and I don't remember that I said he created everything includes the devil.
There are some beliefs that refers that the Truth and Lie are like enemy brothers the same can be apply on God and Devil.
No. At one time this would have been considered valid, because people generally believed that only humans were capable of empathy and compassion. That's why the words are so similar. The problem with that is they were wrong. That's why their meanings are different.
The word humanity have different meanings like - people in general, the state of being a person or the quality of being humane.
But in this sentence
The Judge was praised for his courage and humanity. take the third meaning of humanity that is the quality of being humane than I think you will get your answer.
The sentences are almost exact opposites. I said that the two words are distinct, while you said they are identical.
You don't understand it. As you said
All human beings have humanity in other words as you said "
Humanity is the state of being human", I have already agreed with this in my previous comments.
As you said
but only some have humaneness. and I said
he quality of being humane.
Yeah, i know that. but that completely overrules the possibility of the parent, teacher, or even angels to be wrong. In the past, women can't go to school at the same degree as men. why is that? Parents in the past are deeply influenced by social stigma that girls can't ( without any good reasons ) go to school. that is an example of how parents can be wrong.
Yes, I know about it. As I said "no one is perfect" so I agree that even elders make mistakes. But at that time the people were not so smart as compaired to today's date, at that time they easlily believes what someone says.
Here our common sense lies, how efficiently we can distinguish between good or bad (often reffered smartness).
I once have a teacher that taught me at elementary that the sky is blue because it got reflected of the water in the sea, while only the opposite is true. another example of how teachers can be wrong.
I don't said that about education I said it about moral values.
Lucifer, as an angel. wanted everyone to worship him, causing him to become a fallen angel. so as you can see, even angels can be wrong.
Its us who make us.
For instance :- One boy who is very bad in behaviour, scolded many times by the teachers, parents or other elders. But still no change in his behaviour. This means its us who make us.
Because God already known about that ( because he is all knowing), he could have just not create Lucifer in the first place. but he did create him anyways, so that thing is willingly and purposely created by god. the only way you're going to negate this is by stating that God is NOT all knowing, but you can't do that right? so just accept this as a fact
No God did not created the devil. Lucifer himself became a devil as I said its us who make us. Maybe god have given punishment to the Lucifer for his works but he still don't get it and he choosed the way of distruction. Anyways can you tell me who created the God?
Because God is all powerful and all knowing, he also would known if a devil would come inside a person and could just make the thing disappeared. not only that, he could even annihilate all the devil on this planet or on this universe if he wanted to, making a world with no evil on any kind. but because that's not the case, we have to assume that God created the devil as a part of His thought through plan
Lucifer himself became a devil as I said its us who make us.
God and Devil can't be like enemy brothers. because if it was true, that implies they have about the same strength, so it would invalidate your argument that God is all powerful and all knowing. also, because Lucifer is initially an angel, obviously God is higher than the devil
"God is all powerful and all knowing" that is according to us because we only worship to god.
If you will ask to a person who worship devil, he will definetely say that "devil is all powerful and all knowing". I believe that the God and Devil are of same strength. But also sometimes good is less powerful that bad but the efforts of good makes him win.
why would God purposely created an enemy anyways? if the devil is really an enemy of god, then why hasn't the word "devil" begone from the world anyways. cause if you ask me, God can just destroy the devil with ease if he wanted to, yet he did not did that. unless you can find a rational explanation as to why would god not kill his enemies, i'll consider you as not rational
Because they both are of same strength.