ForumsWEPRIs It Right For Atheists To Celebrate Christmas?

159 27036
thepossum
offline
thepossum
3,035 posts
Nomad

The topic says it all. I don't think that it's right. Especially last year when a lot of atheists complained about Christmas trees being called Christmas trees. How stupid is that?

  • 159 Replies
samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

Christanity stole the holiday from Pagans.


Not stole not took we replaced it we don't say you can't celebrate the old holidays so obviously at the time it was created christmas was more poplular than the pagan holiday's in america atleast
Xzeno
offline
Xzeno
2,300 posts
Nomad

Christanity stole the holiday from Pagans.
Successful troll!

Anyway, it is still a religious holiday, whether christen or pagan, and the question about atheists remains unchanged.
Communist
offline
Communist
522 posts
Nomad

Well I'm atheist and I celebrate it, I think it would be depressing if there was no such thing as christmas! It's a time of joy and kindness, which should apply to all. Who cares if it is mainly sponsered by Christanity? No one but people who beleive in segregation.

lily92606
offline
lily92606
216 posts
Nomad

atheist
should not call it christmass they should call it x mass it is called christ mass
samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

should not call it christmass they should call it x mass it is called christ mass


Actauly x-mass is just as religious...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-mas

Who cares if it is mainly sponsered by Christanity? No one but people who beleive in segregation.


I agree with that
Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,656 posts
Jester

Very few super religious people see christmas as something super relious. To many it is a cultural festival, a tradition. Something to look forward to, and be happy about. A time when you can be with your family and friends.

Snakebite
offline
Snakebite
995 posts
Nomad

If one doesn't take this time to remember the birth of Christ, I believe it's perfectly acceptable to use this time to spend with family. In my family, this is the ONLY time I get to see my biological father, and most extended family. This thread is only going to keep causing fights because no one will agree on a "happy medium". I think we all need to remember the forum rules on this one; respect one's opinion. We all are from different backgrounds, religions, cultures, etc. Why don't we try to stop singling out a person's views, and just start at the very least, showing some compassion!

GeneralPerseus
offline
GeneralPerseus
10 posts
Nomad

Christmas is not only about Christ being born anymore. In fact, it was never only about that. (In my opinion) The bible is meant to be a symbolic book about morality, so Christs Birth represents a gift to humanity (among other things), or generosity. Thus, any generous person can celebrate Christmas. Besides that, I think that we should let anybody do whatever the hell they want (that is legal and morally correct). It isn't about whether or not it is "right" for a people to celebrate a holiday. Really, if we don't let them, we shouldn't let ourselves. Which would be confusing.

tanstaafl28
offline
tanstaafl28
335 posts
Farmer

no its wrong and even Atheists know theres a god the devil knows too


Lily, you are engaging in wishful thinking.
Snakebite
offline
Snakebite
995 posts
Nomad

That is what I'm trying to say!! It shouldn't be our choice whether or not someone else should celebrate Christmas.

tanstaafl28
offline
tanstaafl28
335 posts
Farmer

That last link isn't quite as good as this one:

The Pagan History of Christmas

bigbrain
offline
bigbrain
1,594 posts
Nomad

That would be weird, cause they don't belive in God. There would be no Christmas if there was no Jesus. That holyday is created because of him, so, atheist shouldn't celebrate Christmas.

samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

That would be weird, cause they don't belive in God. There would be no Christmas if there was no Jesus. That holyday is created because of him, so, atheist shouldn't celebrate Christmas.


Right and dont say the crap about the pagan holidays christmas is celebrated for Jesus, but i would say they can celebrate it...we had this answered by the 3rd page...
Zophia
offline
Zophia
9,424 posts
Scribe

Honestly it loks like no one here bothers reading the previous pages.

We have concluded that Christmas originates from and is affected by old pagan traditions and celebrations.

Those who see Christmas as something very religious obviously think atheists shouldn't celebrate it, but most people these days do not see it as something that religious.

Why would it not be right or them to have a good time as the rest of you?

Stormchaser
offline
Stormchaser
278 posts
Nomad

Ya, why can't Atheists have some Christmas joy.

Showing 121-135 of 159