ForumsThe TavernFire or Ice

86 12845
DeepFriedPeanuts
offline
DeepFriedPeanuts
118 posts
Nomad

Who would win? (not the dumb Christmas people)

  • 86 Replies
Xzeno
offline
Xzeno
2,300 posts
Nomad

Dumb what? You mean Heat Miser and Snow Miser? I don't see the dumb there, so you must mean something else.

Agent_86
offline
Agent_86
2,127 posts
Nomad

Well, at first, fire would melt the ice, but then the resulting water would put out the fire.

But if the ice was strong enough, it would snuff out the fire by not leaving enough heat for the fire to go.

And if the fire was overpowering, it would vaporize the ice instantly.

plokkey
offline
plokkey
4,546 posts
Jester

Yea, as agent said. If you put a block of ice on a burning match head, the fire would die out, but if you drop a small cube of ice into a bonfire, the fire would conquer. So it depends on how much of each element.

lily92606
offline
lily92606
216 posts
Nomad

so its a pending thing

darkd00m
offline
darkd00m
505 posts
Nomad

I'd say fire, it could melt it.

russianfreak
offline
russianfreak
1,840 posts
Farmer

it is impossible they bolth have weaknesses and strengh and they over come each other but most ppl belive that fire would win ice cause it would melt it.

sambolini
offline
sambolini
5 posts
Nomad

this question is totally circumstantial, so it has no correct, overall, answer!!!

GMSaitanGM
offline
GMSaitanGM
93 posts
Nomad

Hey i find there both pretty equal in some ways the fire beats ice sometime's and the ice beats fire depending on how big the fire ice or how big the ice is.

=GM=

choazmachine
offline
choazmachine
1,041 posts
Nomad

Ok if the amount where the same and the fire had infinite fuel and the temperature was below freezing, fire would win. For water is not ice, just the liquid form. So water is not part of this vs. match so I say fire.
But it ALL depends on amount.

DeepFriedPeanuts
offline
DeepFriedPeanuts
118 posts
Nomad

We know both have pro's and con's but in your eye's who would win

theone99
offline
theone99
3,033 posts
Shepherd

fire no doubt, it would melt the ice right away..obvious.

plokkey
offline
plokkey
4,546 posts
Jester

Ok if the amount where the same and the fire had infinite fuel and the temperature was below freezing, fire would win. For water is not ice, just the liquid form. So water is not part of this vs. match so I say fire.
But it ALL depends on amount.


That's like saying a shapeshifter doesn't count because when it changes form.

fire no doubt, it would melt the ice right away..obvious.


A giant block of ice can suffocate a fire.
chibilin
offline
chibilin
131 posts
Nomad

Fire !!!!!
I like it so much because its some kind of gas that needs something to burn to exist!!
Itsgreat fire will win no doubt

theone99
offline
theone99
3,033 posts
Shepherd

A giant block of ice can suffocate a fire


Thats if it was inside a block and would be impossible to start because the person trying to light it would never be alive, thus ending in a forfeit win..but yeah fire, in an open battle.
plokkey
offline
plokkey
4,546 posts
Jester

Thats if it was inside a block and would be impossible to start because the person trying to light it would never be alive, thus ending in a forfeit win..but yeah fire, in an open battle.


The fire would still be extinguished.
Showing 1-15 of 86