ForumsThe TavernFire or Ice

86 12842
DeepFriedPeanuts
offline
DeepFriedPeanuts
118 posts
Nomad

Who would win? (not the dumb Christmas people)

  • 86 Replies
_S_K_E_
offline
_S_K_E_
731 posts
Nomad

Ok, fire melts ice, then the water from the ice can put out the fire, and when it gets cold again, the ice is formed back.

kingmike123
offline
kingmike123
383 posts
Peasant

fire would win. fire is awesome.

Fyrefox
offline
Fyrefox
2,120 posts
Farmer

Ok, fire melts ice, then the water from the ice can put out the fire, and when it gets cold again, the ice is formed back

Very well put S_K_E...my choice is Ice.
darkboy58465846
offline
darkboy58465846
132 posts
Nomad

if same amount id say fire because the water left from the ild be very little and be evaporated very quickly

Graham
offline
Graham
8,047 posts
Nomad

how about a room of absolute 0 vs a supernova

Fyrefox
offline
Fyrefox
2,120 posts
Farmer

In retrospect it all depends on how much ice and how big the fire is.

_S_K_E_
offline
_S_K_E_
731 posts
Nomad

if same amount id say fire because the water left from the ild be very little and be evaporated very quickly


That's how rain clouds are formed, from evaporation! The water goes up from the ice, if evaporated and it will rain down on the fire! Sometimes fire can wear out very quickly.
madgamer012
offline
madgamer012
729 posts
Nomad

depends how much of each no doubt. A wildfire vs. cube of ice? fire wins. I glacier in the antarctic vs. a tiny campfire? Ice wins. But in equal amounts it depends more on the environment. In the desert or forest or a dry environment during daytime especially with winds(except desert), fire would grow more powerful and the melted ice would have been evaporated or just sink into the sand. The winds would also carry fire embers and start more fires (i.e. Santa Ana winds). And vice versa. But my choice is ice because eventually in cities a fire fighter puts out the fire with melted ice or should i say water.

Blkasp
offline
Blkasp
1,303 posts
Nomad

It is a question that has no awnser unless you know the Size of the Fire and the Ice.

supersmiley
offline
supersmiley
842 posts
Nomad

fia!!!

GodofBlades
offline
GodofBlades
241 posts
Nomad

i think fire would win because fire melts ice and it is not the ice that puts out the fire but the water from the ice.I love loop holes

firetail_madness
offline
firetail_madness
20,540 posts
Blacksmith

The fire would melt the ice, however if the total volume of ice was small then the resulting water would not be enough to put out the fire, so fire wins.


Let's say it was a huge glacier...
Gladitator
offline
Gladitator
75 posts
Nomad

Well the fire would burn part of the glacier depends on how much fire you use and what part of the glacier you hit.

GodofBlades
offline
GodofBlades
241 posts
Nomad

also fire wins because you can't make smores on a block of ice ^_^

GodofBlades
offline
GodofBlades
241 posts
Nomad

and because you can get tans (and hopefuly no skin cancer!) from the sun but cold climates only give you frost bite (and maybe loss of a few toes)

Showing 31-45 of 86