ForumsWEPRIs Stealing for Survival: Good or Bad?

199 54653
Crazy_Chris_84
offline
Crazy_Chris_84
139 posts
Peasant

In these troubling times we see in the news that more and more people are losing their jobs. Hence, we see a rise in criminal activity. There was a news article that just recently caught my attention in the Wall Street Journal, âBusinesses Say Theft by Their Workers Is Up.â Here is the link to the article if you wish to see it, just copy and paste it in your search bar:

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122896381748896999.html

The article is not the main topic, but it serves as more of a reference to this discussion.

Is stealing for survival good or is it still considered as plain stealing no matter what the motive?

  • 199 Replies
random_player_of_ag
offline
random_player_of_ag
2,636 posts
Nomad

Well, if you steal because you do not have anything to live (money, food and such) i think that sealing is acceptable even that people think that you are a thief.
But if you steal for greed it is WRONG.

Thank you and have a nice day

random_player_of_ag
offline
random_player_of_ag
2,636 posts
Nomad

I am so sorry.I meant stealing not "sealing". :S
Sorry for the incorrect word :S

orgy
offline
orgy
55 posts
Nomad

stealing is always wrong....
if you dont have anything you can ask help from your goverment
or rich people...or you can try to find a job...

woody_7007
offline
woody_7007
2,662 posts
Peasant

There is no overiding moral argument in my opinion. Everything has to be looked at a case by case basis- thats why there is a judicial system. Everyone has their own motives and reasoning behind it. Its impossible to generalise on such a cmplex issue. Let the judges decide.

tanstaafl28
offline
tanstaafl28
336 posts
Farmer

An otherwise honest person who steals because they themselves, or their family, are starving, is not necessarily "bad," or "wrong," however, there are so many charitable organizations they should have exhausted in an attempt to find food before they resort to theft.

Eshploded
offline
Eshploded
469 posts
Nomad

According to our government stealing is bad, and since we abide to them, then it would also be considered bad for us to step outside the law and steal.

beaver148
offline
beaver148
32 posts
Nomad

With the state and federal provided funds, it is literally impossible to not have enough money if you have not
A) Dropped out of Highschool
B) Are addicted to alchohol or drugs
C) Had a baby before you were ready.
I am not just blowing smoke, my dad was laid off last christmas, and we were on food stamps. but, he got a new job, and now we're fine.

Drace
offline
Drace
3,880 posts
Nomad

Is stealing for survival good or is it still considered as plain stealing no matter what the motive?


Yes, its perfectly moral. Stealing is always wrong is total crap.
tennisman24
offline
tennisman24
4,682 posts
Farmer

i think it is ok as long as it is not something huge like diamonds

tennisman24
offline
tennisman24
4,682 posts
Farmer

i think it is ok as long as it is not something huge like diamonds

Craze77
offline
Craze77
813 posts
Peasant

Of course. If it is for ur life yes.

crazjayz
offline
crazjayz
243 posts
Nomad

Stealing is stealing, which is illegal. Just keep in mind, if you steal, it's always at the expense of someone else. Moreover, you have no idea what "situation" that person/people are in either.

Take for instance, you're a hostess at some small mom and pop joint. Every night you work, you take a couple bucks from the cashier whenever a waitress asks you to help out and grab a couple checks (which isn't technically part of your job). So you steal from this mom and pop restaurant, because you're some student, barely cutting it, studying and working for minimum wage. Plus, it's a couple bucks every time, not much and never noticed.

Now what if that mom and pop were barely cutting it? They were sacrificing all they had for this restaurant? Took out multiple loans, were thousands of dollars in debt, and were pinching pennies at the end of every month. You just make $100 bucks last month stealing from the cashier. You just stole $100 from that mom and pop, who are working hard as hell to make ends meet.

To make it interesting, you just found out that mom and pop are now borrowing from your parents to make ends meet since financial institutions won't loan them any more money.

You never know who stealing will affect. That's why I'm all against it. Work hard for you life, don't f-ck it up for others and spend your life looking/depending on shortcuts and/or handouts.

3v3rnoob
offline
3v3rnoob
230 posts
Nomad

i frown upon all who said that stealing is ok. usually, if you are put in a position that you justify stealing to yourself, usually, you put yourself there with drugs or your just not capable of swallowing your pride and admitting that it's wrong. it will hurt some one, as was said before. if it's not your fault that you're in said position, then it should be fine to ask for help. there's always someone who cares. so instead of stealing what isn't yours, take what's offered to you. stealing hurts everyone, and in the end, the only one that you hurt is yourself.

miguelin11
offline
miguelin11
2,905 posts
Nomad

hmmm... if you stel you go to jail, but if you don't steal you won't have money to survive

but i'm with BAD
only because someone stole my wallet a few weeks ago =P

3v3rnoob
offline
3v3rnoob
230 posts
Nomad

lol..... that was simple, but brought up the fas that there is a perspective part to this argument too: if your stolen from, you'll say it's bad, but if you're the theif, you'll say it's ok..... try putting yourself in the otherperson's shoes

Showing 1-15 of 199