ForumsWEPRwas hitler a great person? (not leader)

172 29082
SirLegendary
offline
SirLegendary
16,586 posts
Duke

What do you think of Hitler as a person. Some would say he is awesome some like me would say he wasnt a very good person. And maybe what your saying is true.

  • 172 Replies
samdawghomie
offline
samdawghomie
3,550 posts
Peasant

He actually wanted to become a preist before he got enlisted for the Austrian army.

FireflyIV
offline
FireflyIV
3,224 posts
Nomad

and sonam, the dude seemed relatively sane before the nazi biz.


If by sane you mean not anti-Semitic, then it is most likely his anti-Semitism between 1908-1913 when he was a down and out in Austria. During the war there are records from his comrades commenting on how anti-Semitic he already was. His views just became more refined after he joined the German Workers Party. His hatred of Jews was already there.
goumas13
offline
goumas13
4,752 posts
Grand Duke

i think he made some paintings, but he wasn't a good painter

FireflyIV
offline
FireflyIV
3,224 posts
Nomad

i think he made some paintings, but he wasn't a good painter


The area of art he was interested in was not very popular, and so he didn't have much competition to get into the arts academ. The fact he failed the exam shows how poor he must have been.
Pazx
offline
Pazx
5,845 posts
Peasant

He was a figurehead. That would mean that whatever he did was slightly less worse.

But, he killed his own kin. He was a terrible person, and a leader who rules with an iron fist.

goumas13
offline
goumas13
4,752 posts
Grand Duke

No only a leader who rules with an iron fist, but a bad leader, he made so many mistakes

Pazx
offline
Pazx
5,845 posts
Peasant

@goumas, it even states in the title that this is asking about him as a person, not him as a leader.

Even though they are similar.

goumas13
offline
goumas13
4,752 posts
Grand Duke

yes i know but it depends if you are a good leader, from what kind of person you are

VoltCruelerz
offline
VoltCruelerz
501 posts
Nomad

the guy spent time on the streets, was abused, hit with mustard gas, shot, etc. It doesn't surprise me that he didn't turn out so well...

Maverick4
offline
Maverick4
6,800 posts
Peasant

his anti0semetism was most likely born when he was living on the streets in the austrian capital when he wanted to become an artist. Alot of jews were rich, as they wer bankers, lawyers, etc, so seing some one 'below you' having more money than you...

Moegreche
offline
Moegreche
3,826 posts
Duke

Lots of people are raised in less than favorable conditions. Where I live, there are a ton of old baptists that are quite wealthy. I have a great deal of animosity toward these people, but I wouldn't kill any of them. Nor would I order them to be sent to work camps or anything like that.
Certainly someone's environment plays a role in the kind of person they will become, but ultimately we make our own choices. A serial killer who was sexually abused as a child is still a serial killer and should be held responsible for their actions.
But Hitler's life was not that of a lowly street urchin, as some of you seem to be making it out. In "Mein Kampf" Hitler tries to make it seem like he struggled through life. In reality, he was able to live for a number of years in Vienna off an inheritance from his father. That would indicate they at least had money. There is evidence to indicate his father was abusive, but again, that does not excuse anything. And the only time he was ever shot (as far as I know) was when he shot himself. This indicates to me that he knew full well what he was doing was heinously wrong and didn't want to face the consequences of his actions. Thus, there is no environmental excuse for his actions and he was mentally competent enough to understand what he was doing and the consequences of his actions.

GreatestSoloEver
offline
GreatestSoloEver
1,361 posts
Nomad

He did many great things for his people....but he also did really "bad" things. Oh and I went to go see his hideout/nest thing when I lived in Germany. =]

phsycomonkey
offline
phsycomonkey
789 posts
Nomad

Define Great... In my definition, he got high most nights, killed himself and his wife, he was very violentm I wouuldn't say he's great.

Kalb789
offline
Kalb789
639 posts
Baron

very smart but very messed up, evil, etc.

digi_cai
offline
digi_cai
272 posts
Viceroy

He was great! Simply a genius! And genius are not wrong...

Showing 91-105 of 172