ForumsPopular MediaWorst Book-Movie Switch You Have Ever Seen

95 12584
Moabarmorgamer
offline
Moabarmorgamer
8,570 posts
Nomad

This thread is about the gross misrepresentation of books by movies! Name the one movie you've seen about a book you've read that HORRIBLY changes it. You know what I'm talking about. You read a book you like and get hyped up when you hear they're making a movie about it. Then you see the movie...and it is waaaaay different/worse than the book. Here's where you post the movie/book names and how they were worse than the book.
Mine is Eragon. I mean...they changed/chopped off...sooooooo much! I was really disappointed in it. I mean, a few changes are okay. But the list goes on and on. They didn't mention Orik or the Twins, they changed Murtagh hugely, they changed Brom's method of death to a more dramatic(and stupid) thing, and they totally misrepresented Roran and Saphira.
All I can say is, if they're making a movie about the second book:
1. I am so not watching it
2. They are gonna have serious problems about the crucial bits they chopped off of the first one.
I guess it was a good movie. But I went into that theater expecting the book...and I got a totally different thing, and a huge disappointment.

  • 95 Replies
wuut
offline
wuut
231 posts
Nomad

Do TV shows to movies count? If so Star Trek was the worst (>.&lt

jonnypants23
offline
jonnypants23
1,353 posts
Farmer

I haven't watched eragon , but im just reading the book ..
I believe the spiderwick movie was an epic fail..the whole movie was digital -_-

jdoggparty
offline
jdoggparty
5,860 posts
Nomad

Long books. They can't fit as much. But one was the city of ember, that movie had the same plot but what they did was way diferent.

I have a feeling The Lightning Thief is going to be like that. I hope not

Armony
offline
Armony
58 posts
Nomad

Harry Potter.. it got really noticable from the third movie on. Those and Eragon are the reason I hardly watch movies made after books any more.

Moabarmorgamer
offline
Moabarmorgamer
8,570 posts
Nomad

Yeah I get the bad feeling the Lightning Thief is going to bomb. It's got so many things in it, it's probably going to be cheesy and with bad acting. Plus, I don't trust the director. Why? It's the same director as the Harry Potter movies, and we all know about those. It's got Pierce Brosnan in it: the guy who plays Bond. I mean, Uma Thurman is in it, and she's cool, but I just get this bad feeling that it's going to totally blow. Waste of my money, but I'm still going to see it.

Showing 91-95 of 95