ForumsWEPRDeath Penalty- For or Against?

278 49004
nichodemus
offline
nichodemus
14,991 posts
Grand Duke

Title says it all.

Preferably...can someone give me arguments for the death penalty? School debate >.<

  • 278 Replies
rgchristmas
offline
rgchristmas
21 posts
Nomad

cool. :-) That is an excellent thing to say. Well I am beat. See ya.

wistress
offline
wistress
262 posts
Peasant

I decided to revive this thread after 4 days because I found an article I think all of you would like to read. It's a long article, but well worth the read. The article is HERE.

It's for reasons such as this article that I don't believe in the death penalty. The problem with sentencing someone to death is that the above (please see article) type of scenario has happened at least 14 times since 1976 when the death penalty was reinstated (innocence found through DNA testing after their death) ...so until we find a better way of processing evidence and records, the death penalty should be banned or abolished. How many innocent people have to be killed before that is understood?
BTW - I believe there have been more then the 14 innocent people stated above ...those 14 case just happened to have fluids from the crime scene still "sound" enough to perform DNA testing on.

Morally, how can we condone killing a person when that's the reason they are being killed? Does it show that WE are valuing life? NO, therefore why should we expect them to? Murder for murder is not the way to teach right from wrong.

Financially, it's more expensive to keep someone on death row then it is to keep a person incarcerated for life, so that argument goes down the tubes.

What IS the justification of sentencing someone to death? An eye for an eye? Is that the society we want to live in?

<OK - stepping off my soap box now>

Grandslam
offline
Grandslam
144 posts
Nomad

Well, I would, though I hope it never happens. One last time you know?


Really. So if your mom killed someone, you would want her to die?
orfict
offline
orfict
124 posts
Nomad

An eye for an eye, but you better make damn sure you got the guy who poked the eye out.

wistress
offline
wistress
262 posts
Peasant

An eye for an eye, but you better make **** sure you got the guy who poked the eye out.


That's the problem, our justice system is fallible. They haven't made sure that "they got the guy who poked the eye out" 100% of the time. If you are dealing with someones fate, you better make sure you are 100% correct, not 99%, or even 99.9%.

Really. So if your mom killed someone, you would want her to die?


I agree with you Grandslam ... I wouldn't want any one of my family or friends to suffer through the death penalty, therefore, how can I justify wanting other peoples friends and family to suffer a fate that I don't want to experience?
FishermanJE
offline
FishermanJE
38 posts
Nomad

Capital punishment,hang'em high.

Grandslam
offline
Grandslam
144 posts
Nomad

I agree with you Grandslam ... I wouldn't want any one of my family or friends to suffer through the death penalty, therefore, how can I justify wanting other peoples friends and family to suffer a fate that I don't want to experience?


It is not really suffering. Just a shot.

I'm happy you agree with me though.
RSlFoyle
offline
RSlFoyle
1 posts
Nomad

for.

Showing 271-278 of 278