ForumsWEPR[concluded] Was Jesus real?

453 74710
holt24
offline
holt24
1,133 posts
Nomad

This is not about whether or not he was the son of God but whether he actually existed.Most atheists agree that he did live but there are some who don't so what are you're thoughts?

  • 453 Replies
Avorne
offline
Avorne
3,085 posts
Nomad

You're gonna need more evidence than that - for a start you need to prove that Jesus existed in the capacity that the Bible claims.

Matrix159
offline
Matrix159
337 posts
Nomad

Well since everyone is just insulting another person because they don't have "reasoning" for their "opinions" or some other stuff, I'm not even going to bother with this topic anymore.

And yes you can try insulting me by turning my words around and everything, but frankly, I just don't care anymore.

Asherlee
offline
Asherlee
5,001 posts
Shepherd

Has someone listed the historical documents that reference Jesus of the Bible? All I know of is the Dead Sea Scrolls, which were written sometime between the Old and New Testament. AND we would need to read the "original" Bible to make an informed decision on this. All of these edited version just toss the validity out the window.

Side note, I've always wondered why John the Baptist had to baptize Jesus, when he is supposed to be the son of God?

Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

Asherlee, I do believe Jesus was baptized to fulfill a prophesy in the Old Testament.

http://www.christiancourier.com/articles/584-why-was-jesus-baptized

This link is not really in direct correlation of christian v atheist, but I hope it provides some insight.

Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad
Asherlee
offline
Asherlee
5,001 posts
Shepherd

While I am reading this, Cinna. Could you, or someone else tell me about the other prophesies that were supposed to be fulfilled to be the Messiah? Which is where I wanted to go with this.

I know two, I believe. He was supposed to be son of David and from Bethlehem, not Nazareth, right?

Avorne
offline
Avorne
3,085 posts
Nomad
MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

Anyway, don't most of you guys have school?


I work from home, that's how I can be on so much.

I do wonder whether any of the supposed historical documents that show Jesus existed in any capacity are actually correct - I doubt any of them were written when Jesus was supposedly alive.


No there are no contemporary documents of Jesus. There are also a number of people in power around the 3rd century who were willing to lie about historical facts in order to get more people to convert to Christianity. Interestingly enough much of the extra Biblical material on Jesus appeared around that era. That's not to say it was all falsified but it does mean we should be very critical of it.

Well since everyone is just insulting another person because they don't have "reasoning" for their "opinions" or some other stuff, I'm not even going to bother with this topic anymore.


He was putting forth his opinions as facts and expecting everyone to just accept them as such.

Has someone listed the historical documents that reference Jesus of the Bible? All I know of is the Dead Sea Scrolls, which were written sometime between the Old and New Testament.


the dead sea scrolls are a document of the old testament, So it wouldn't include Jesus.
I remember coming across a site not to long ago that had a pretty good unbiased take on the extra Biblical material, I will try and find it again.

AND we would need to read the "original" Bible to make an informed decision on this.


We don't have an original copy. as far as the old testament the dead sea scrolls are the closest we have, but even they are just copies. Not sure of the oldest copy of the new testament though.
Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

Avorne, how is it not to be said that these prophecies are still waiting to be fulfilled?

Asherlee; Wha..?

Matrix159
offline
Matrix159
337 posts
Nomad

He was putting forth his opinions as facts and expecting everyone to just accept them as such.


Well it's either that, or you just received them as "facts". Either way it's still childish for trying to make everything he says sound bad.
Asherlee
offline
Asherlee
5,001 posts
Shepherd

We don't have an original copy. as far as the old testament the dead sea scrolls are the closest we have, but even they are just copies


Yet, I've met and talked to several Christians that do not accept the Dead Sea Scrolls as authentic. Why didn't all of the documents from DSS make it to the Bible?

Cinna, what are you whating?
MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

Avorne, how is it not to be said that these prophecies are still waiting to be fulfilled?


If the prophecies are yet to be fulfilled, and they must be fulfilled by the Messiah, then logically one cannot assert that ANY person has been the Messiah yet, as the informatin we've been given as to how to ascertain who is the true savior has yet to be fulfilled. It is for this same reason that the Jews reject the idea of Jesus as the messiah, although they count him among YHWH's prophets.
MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

Not the site I was looking for but here's something.
http://www.nobeliefs.com/exist.htm

This is very long, but it's a lecture of the study of the new testament from Yale University. There are 26 parts, each about an hour long. This is the intro.
http://academicearth.org/lectures/intro-new-testament

MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

Yet, I've met and talked to several Christians that do not accept the Dead Sea Scrolls as authentic. Why didn't all of the documents from DSS make it to the Bible?


It doesn't surprise me that there are Christians that don't accept them as they often say things that don't match with the version we have today. There are around something like 30 gospels not included in the new testament that were written.
GenericAtheist
offline
GenericAtheist
3 posts
Nomad

Cinna, what are you whating?


Well, he is obvouisly in awe of our intense logic and is a christian which makes him rather unintelligent
Showing 406-420 of 453