ForumsWEPRWhat if Jesus popped out of thin air?

105 22502
LEAPretard
offline
LEAPretard
1,328 posts
Nomad

Ok, I know all you Muslims, Atheists, buddists and others are thinking: wtf is this stupid question??? (I myself am an abuser and I don't belive in Cheese)


But what if it happened? No matter how science or any Oher thing proves it wrong, what would you do?





Stupid Questions Rock.

  • 105 Replies
StDrake
offline
StDrake
194 posts
Lord

if i'm dead and i do see god then i will instandly believe in him even tho i did not believe in him when i was alive. then god can no longer punish me for not believing in him because i do =)

err no, you will not believe - you will know
knowledge is not faith, faith is not knowledge well..at least in my view. You could easily say "seeing is believing" and I don't have anything sensible to argue with that
still..
Faith is necessary for salvation

Favourite saying of slavedriver priests..or fanatics. Ok, let's sa faith IS necessary for salvation, but even if you don't have faith in God, God has faith in you. Ain't he neat?
faith is necessary to look stupid against athiests

That would be fanaticism actually.
god will save me because he loves me and forgives me for not believing

You've just expressed faith in God. Doesn't it feel better
Well of course don't forget you might make more blunders than just disbelief to postpone your salvation. Be an *** and it will be harder to forgive you.
MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

Then you are both wrong. Faith is necessary for salvation. Heaven is defined as being perfect union(relationship) with God. How can you have any relationship with God if you do not believe in Him? If you do not believe in God you cannot be saved.


If they showed they existed i would believe they were real. The requirement of faith is a complete load. It's asking they we believe without anything supporting the claim of existence. If we were to apply this requirement elsewhere we would likely regard the person as gullible and easily taken in. For example: You just have to have faith that you have a dead relative from Zimbabwe who left you millions of dollars.

If God does exist he gave us the ability to reason. Part of the process of reasoning is to not simply take things on faith but to further investigate and only believe that which is proven.

My response: Those circumstances are obviously going to be different so my guess this they would be based off of living a moral life.


Actually given you line of thinking here my response would be "The why tell us in the first place?"

No biggie, I'm just a few steps ahead of the game :P


None of your steps would have been how I would have responded so your Q&A fails.

Be an *** and it will be harder to forgive you.


How could it be any harder for a supposed all loving being?
StDrake
offline
StDrake
194 posts
Lord

How could it be any harder for a supposed all loving being?

Harder..on the sinner Love does not necessarily deny an examplary lesson on why evil isn't the way to go (also called punishment, but the kind that will let you learn)
xNightwish
offline
xNightwish
1,608 posts
Nomad

I bet angels have a topic : what if xNightwish popped out of thin air.

partydevil
offline
partydevil
5,129 posts
Jester


Harder..on the sinner Love does not necessarily deny an examplary lesson on why evil isn't the way to go (also called punishment, but the kind that will let you learn)


but god is all loving and and all forgiving. he will forgive me for not believing.
hojoko
offline
hojoko
508 posts
Peasant

but god is all loving and and all forgiving. he will forgive me for not believing.


I assume your parents would also love and forgive you even if you screwed up really badly. Doesn't mean you won't be punished though.
farrowking37
offline
farrowking37
610 posts
Nomad

if Jesus popped out of midair i would say "Nope. Chuck Testa."

cowmaster1
offline
cowmaster1
676 posts
Shepherd

If they showed they existed i would believe they were real. The requirement of faith is a complete load. It's asking they we believe without anything supporting the claim of existence. If we were to apply this requirement elsewhere we would likely regard the person as gullible and easily taken in. For example: You just have to have faith that you have a dead relative from Zimbabwe who left you millions of dollars.




so are you just assuming that i blindly believe in God? And what 'supports the claim of existence' in your opinion?

god will save me because he loves me and forgives me for not believing

Nope. God will accept your choice for not believing in him and acknowledge that you do not want a relationship with him and woulnd't force you to go to heaven against your free will.



ldslarson, what church are you from??
dudeguy45
offline
dudeguy45
2,917 posts
Peasant

It would be like that Family Guy.

deathbewithyou
offline
deathbewithyou
534 posts
Nomad

There should have been a question what if christian people disapeared and we were left behind. what if he was really the son of God. That would be a better question than this one.

frisko12
offline
frisko12
420 posts
Nomad

but god is all loving and and all forgiving. he will forgive me for not believing.

no he wont.
MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

so are you just assuming that i blindly believe in God? And what 'supports the claim of existence' in your opinion?


Your telling me you take it on faith so I don't need to assume your going about it blindly, that's what your flat out telling me.

I've listed what it would take for me to believe a number of times. Out of them the biggest one would be him sowing up and demonstrating that he is who h says he is by doing something only God could do such as create matter from nothing and do all this in a way I can be sure it wasn't trickery or a hallucination of some sort.
I know it sounds like a tall order but this one is at the top of the list and I'm sure it wouldn't be a chore for an omnipotent being.

Nope. God will accept your choice for not believing in him and acknowledge that you do not want a relationship with him and woulnd't force you to go to heaven against your free will.


How can I possibly have a relationship with a being who doesn't demonstrate that he exists? It would be like me trying to have a relationship with a father I never met, or heard from, or even knew existed or not.
hojoko
offline
hojoko
508 posts
Peasant

How can I possibly have a relationship with a being who doesn't demonstrate that he exists? It would be like me trying to have a relationship with a father I never met, or heard from, or even knew existed or not.


I assume the kind of relationship you'd have is one of hoping to meet that father sometime in the future. God would be the same, hoping to meet Him when you die, even if it's just to tell him he's a jerk.
MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

I assume the kind of relationship you'd have is one of hoping to meet that father sometime in the future. God would be the same, hoping to meet Him when you die, even if it's just to tell him he's a jerk.


I would call that wishful thinking, not a relationship.
schuetteg6
offline
schuetteg6
270 posts
Nomad

It would be the coolest thing ever if Jesus popped out! I wouldnt know what to do or say though, let me go prepare my speech. lol

Showing 76-90 of 105