When the game is too short
That and being too easy, too simple and repettitive etc.
A great example: Prototype 2. While in terms of gameplay, it was better than its predecessor, i finished it on normal difficulty in 1 and 1/2 - 2 days and having been killed no more than 10 times!
Another example: Star Wars:Force Unleashed 2. For the same reasons: too short and too easy gameplay.
i hate when im playing a fps game and its just unrealistic overall. it just really rustles my jimmies
Can you please define unrealistic? If you are "hard" on games, you may consider all of the Call of Duty games to be such. Also, unrealistic in what? In terms of gameplay( Like Call of Duty:World at War), or in terms of plot( like Singularity), or both(like Wolfenstein 2009)?