ForumsWEPR[dup] Flag Burning

109 30192
Twistedreality
offline
Twistedreality
23 posts
Nomad

Should it be unconstitutional to Burn the flag?

  • 109 Replies
Drace
offline
Drace
3,880 posts
Nomad

Well Amendment #3 would say that burning a flag is not treason.


Section 3. Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort. No Person shall be convicted of Treason unless on the Testimony of two Witnesses to the same overt Act, or on Confession in open Court. The Congress shall have power to declare the Punishment of Treason, but no Attainder of Treason shall work Corruption of Blood, or Forfeiture except during the Life of the Person attainted.
Twistedreality
offline
Twistedreality
23 posts
Nomad

Well Amendment #3 would say that burning a flag is not treason.


but is it unconstitutional?
RathRaid
offline
RathRaid
129 posts
Nomad

Who cares if a country is bad or not, that is a whole different discussion. Bottom line is, burning a flag of a country is disrespectful, rude, and tells others that your think the country is not as good as yours in some way. A bad country is still a bad country. Correct the bad country, but don't disrespect it, it won't help.

redfan45
offline
redfan45
197 posts
Nomad

Hmm ive been close to treason before then,

redfan45
offline
redfan45
197 posts
Nomad

Back in older times you could be hanged for that i think

kris1027
offline
kris1027
506 posts
Nomad

Bottom line is, burning a flag of a country is disrespectful, rude, and tells others that your think the country is not as good as yours in some way.


So running around and screaming about how you hate your country and why it sucks when compared to ______ and making a sign that said the same would be just as bad as burning a flag? Because people do that all the time.

Being able to dissent against your country and its government is allowed under our bill of rights, the beginning of the constitution. Couldn't burning a flag be compared to freedom of speech? Therefore constitutional?
Drace
offline
Drace
3,880 posts
Nomad

but is it unconstitutional?


Well of course. Amendment #3 is the most relevant and it says nothing. Is there any other amendments which would be against flag burning?

Bottom line is, burning a flag of a country is disrespectful, rude, and tells others that your think the country is not as good as yours in some way.


Thats the whole point of burning a flag.

Correct the bad country, but don't disrespect it, it won't help.


Correction can come through this disrespect. Isn't that the whole point of protests? You can't keep your mouth shut trying to correct something.
razzmonk
offline
razzmonk
496 posts
Nomad

Just a question, would it be hypocritical if the U.S. said that it's unconstitutional to burn a flag, wouldn't it go against the first amendment?

redfan45
offline
redfan45
197 posts
Nomad

well just because its not in their doesint mean it isint treason

Twistedreality
offline
Twistedreality
23 posts
Nomad

Okay, im gonna turn in for the night, but for those of you who are Pro-burning:

How would you feel, if you walked down the street one day, and lo and behold, a crowd cheered as your countries flag was set alight and waved. Isn't that a little extreme?

redfan45
offline
redfan45
197 posts
Nomad

iam not pro-burning, infact i was one of the people who riped a american falg out of a idiot west boro baptist church people who where piciting and about to let their dumb kicks stomp on a flag and i threw a rock at them,
true story to

Drace
offline
Drace
3,880 posts
Nomad

How would you feel, if you walked down the street one day, and lo and behold, a crowd cheered as your countries flag was set alight and waved. Isn't that a little extreme?


Sure it wouldn't feel so well. I am just supporting that it is unconstitutional. I have my set of arguments against the first amendment, you know.

Its hard to say whether I would actually I would support freedom of speech in that way...
razzmonk
offline
razzmonk
496 posts
Nomad

See be warned of rocks being thrown at you for burning your countries flag!

redfan45
offline
redfan45
197 posts
Nomad

haha lol yea but usualy only for the west boro baptist church, if ya dont know of them look them up and prepare to get mad...

firetail_madness
offline
firetail_madness
20,591 posts
Blacksmith

Burn the flag?
It has happened before, but not often...
I don't know about it, because I don't usually watch the news.
But I do believe it is unconstitutional.

Showing 16-30 of 109