ForumsWEPRIs It Right For Atheists To Celebrate Christmas?

159 27033
thepossum
offline
thepossum
3,035 posts
Nomad

The topic says it all. I don't think that it's right. Especially last year when a lot of atheists complained about Christmas trees being called Christmas trees. How stupid is that?

  • 159 Replies
Carlie
offline
Carlie
6,817 posts
Blacksmith

Christmas IS NOT MADE FOR FUN!!! Notice the word Christmas. CHRISTmas.
And it's celebrated on JESUS'S B-DAY TO CELEBRATE HIS BIRTH!!!

Christmas was around before Christ.

Atheists should not celebrate the birth of Jesus Christ. They have no right.

Again, although it is now affiliated with religion, it didn't used to be. I mean, someone could argue that it is wrong that Christians are celebrating Christ on a traditionally pagan holiday.
samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

ignoring the fact that it USED to be a pagan holiday it's everyones right to celebrate it

tempo013
offline
tempo013
581 posts
Nomad

Christmas was not celebrated before the birth of Christ. Other celebrations took place but not Christmas, which again celebrates the birth of Jesus.

tempo013
offline
tempo013
581 posts
Nomad

So, can I celebrate Kwanzaa even though I'm not black? I'm not Jewish but I think I'll celebrate Hanukkah too.

samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

So, can I celebrate Kwanzaa even though I'm not black? I'm not Jewish but I think I'll celebrate Hanukkah too.


Atheists should not celebrate the birth of Jesus Christ. They have no right.


you contradicted yourself
jonnypants23
offline
jonnypants23
1,351 posts
Farmer

Christmas was around before Christ.


Wheres your profe Carlie?

Why does it matter if Atheists want to celebrate christmas or not.
Its none of your buissinis what others do.
tempo013
offline
tempo013
581 posts
Nomad

how did i contradict myself?

Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,656 posts
Jester

[quote]Christmas was around before Christ.

Wheres your profe Carlie?
[/quote]

Pagan/scandinavic/roman solstice festival. The christains blended religion into these festivals to make it easier for the converted peoples to fell well with the religion.
Yule is an old word for this. In Denmark we still use it: Jul. And since Christmas was imported from Europe, it have the same origins.
tempo013
offline
tempo013
581 posts
Nomad

where did you get that info?

Carlie
offline
Carlie
6,817 posts
Blacksmith

Christmas was not celebrated before the birth of Christ. Other celebrations took place but not Christmas, which again celebrates the birth of Jesus.

Right. It wasn't called Christmas, but has many similarities to modern day Christmas celebrations.

So, can I celebrate Kwanzaa even though I'm not black? I'm not Jewish but I think I'll celebrate Hanukkah too.

I know you were going for sarcasm here, but I really don't see the point. I am not Jewish and I celebrate Hanukkah with my Jewish roommate. It is about sharing the experience with someone, not necessarily about the belief. It is about connecting with people on a different level. Just because I am not Jewish does not mean that I cannot take part in lighting a menorah. So I am not Hindu, but we celebrate Hindu holidays with my Hindu roommate. We are sharing the experience, making memories with friends, spreading culture. Tell me how that is wrong in any way?

you contradicted yourself

It was sarcasm...
samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

how did i contradict myself?


It seemed to me(and mabey im wrong) that you said athiests have no right to celebrate christmas but u have a right to celeebrate kunza and haunika which im assuming arent your religon
samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

It was sarcasm...


Sorry i can't catch that in type :P
Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,656 posts
Jester

where did you get that info?

Wikipedia, history books, the internet in generel, dokumentaries....
It is a well known fact.
But again, quote:
A winter festival was the most popular festival of the year in many cultures. Reasons included the fact that less agricultural work needs to be done during the winter, as well as people expecting longer days and shorter nights after the winter solstice in the Northern Hemisphere

Wiki

History.com
tempo013
offline
tempo013
581 posts
Nomad

If you do not believe in religion (atheism) how can you justify celebrating the birth of the son of God. That's contradiction. Maybe they just want presents.

Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,656 posts
Jester

Christmas is celebrated throughout the Christian population, but is also celebrated by many non-Christians as a secular, cultural festival. The holiday is widely celebrated around the world, including in the United States, where it is celebrated by 96% of the population

Also from wiki. Culturel festival. Because of that.
Showing 16-30 of 159