ForumsWEPRADHD: A mental disorder or bored children?

74 10484
Kasic
offline
Kasic
5,552 posts
Jester

I don't know about anyone else, but when I was younger I had behavioural issues. My parents took me to several differnt psychiatrists (I don't know how to spell it) and every one of them initially jumped on, "I beleive he has a form of ADHD, or ADD" after my mom told them that we had already ruled it out, they didn't seem surprised and moved right onto bipolar disorder. In any case, out of around 6-7 differnt physicians, they all went to ADHD first. I grew up, I never had ADHD, I was just a child, immature like many others, I didn't want to wait, I didn't think what others said was important. I want your opinion on whether ADHD is actually a disorder or just a person who is bored and/or easily bored.

  • 74 Replies
Blu3sBr0s
offline
Blu3sBr0s
1,287 posts
Nomad

ADHD is a disorder that is overdiagnosed.

There's your answer

TSL3_needed
offline
TSL3_needed
5,579 posts
Nomad

Bored? Probably not. Being 'bored' more or less constitutes lack of activity, not behavioral problems. ADHD isn't behavioral, and if you're psychiatrists were saying that because you like to act like a fool, they probably aren't very good psychiatrists.

ADHD is an attention disorder. What it does is make you unable to concentrate very well, and therefore unable to do well in school, which is the whole point of the disorder. When that happens, you do act out, but that's only because your brain isn't focusing on what it needs to do. Basically, behavior is an indirect cause, and doesn't even happen in most of the children and adults that have it. If you have a decent amount of maturity, you can handle it.

P.S.: It affects only 5% of boys, so when your doctor just jumps on a relatively rare disorder, they probably aren't a very good doctor :P

Kasic
offline
Kasic
5,552 posts
Jester

No, ADHD isn't when you act like a fool, it's where you don't pay attention and you are constatnly moving. I would get bored in school and start making things out of paper or using a rule and pencils and make little arches and throwing my pencil up and catching it and what not. Where did you get the it only affect 5% of boys? I've always heard from both doctors and other people that boys are diagnosed with it far more often.

TSL3_needed
offline
TSL3_needed
5,579 posts
Nomad

No, ADHD isn't when you act like a fool, it's where you don't pay attention and you are constatnly moving. I would get bored in school and start making things out of paper or using a rule and pencils and make little arches and throwing my pencil up and catching it and what not. Where did you get the it only affect 5% of boys? I've always heard from both doctors and other people that boys are diagnosed with it far more often.


I knew that part.

I just misinterpreted your little paragraph, obviously. I thought you were saying that because you had behavioral issues, you went to a psychiatrist. Sorry.

5% of boys, 2% of girls.

So when they just jump on it, it's not exactly a very good diagnosis.

And I had the same problem, 'cept they realized I didn't have it when the Ritalin made me really aggressive and didn't help.

So

ADHD is a disorder that is overdiagnosed.

There's your answer


Is pretty much the problem.
CONSTANTINOchar
offline
CONSTANTINOchar
79 posts
Nomad

its a disorder.

TSL3_needed
offline
TSL3_needed
5,579 posts
Nomad

its a disorder.


Reasons?
CONSTANTINOchar
offline
CONSTANTINOchar
79 posts
Nomad

none. HAHA. But yeah, it's a disorder. When you really can't concentrate in a not normal way and when you have a short attention span.

TSL3_needed
offline
TSL3_needed
5,579 posts
Nomad

none. HAHA. But yeah, it's a disorder. When you really can't concentrate in a not normal way and when you have a short attention span.


Not sure if I interpreted that, but a lot of people have short attention spans. Just a personality trait, unless you have AD(H)D. Then it can be a problem.
CONSTANTINOchar
offline
CONSTANTINOchar
79 posts
Nomad

what i meant was like, when your attention span, short attention span, is not normal anymore, then you have adhd.

TSL3_needed
offline
TSL3_needed
5,579 posts
Nomad

what i meant was like, when your attention span, short attention span, is not normal anymore, then you have adhd.


Not following you.

I have really bad mood swings sometimes. Am I bipolar now?
CONSTANTINOchar
offline
CONSTANTINOchar
79 posts
Nomad

Hon, you're not bipolar now. HAHA. You just don't get me. For example, some people have really short attention span. But, that's still considered normal especially in kids but when your attention span is really short and lower than the normal,then you have adhd. Got it?

Green12324
offline
Green12324
4,097 posts
Peasant

For example, some people have really short attention span. But, that's still considered normal especially in kids but when your attention span is really short and lower than the normal,then you have adhd. Got it?


Having a short attention span isn't medically normal, but it is common. There's a difference between normal and common.

Just wanted to point that out...
CONSTANTINOchar
offline
CONSTANTINOchar
79 posts
Nomad

what? HAHA

CONSTANTINOchar
offline
CONSTANTINOchar
79 posts
Nomad

well, if it's not normal anymore, then its abnormal, then its a disorder. Right?

Green12324
offline
Green12324
4,097 posts
Peasant

well, if it's not normal anymore, then its abnormal, then its a disorder. Right?


I dip bread sticks in gravy, which is abnormal, but not a disorder. Is it?
Showing 1-15 of 74