ForumsPopular MediaTom Brady VS Peyton Manning

98 19669
Zultimategamer2000
offline
Zultimategamer2000
430 posts
Nomad

as a pats fan, i must say that brady is better. and not just becuz of that, but several other factors as well.
playoff records
brady: 14-4
manning: 9-9
rings
Brady: 3
manning: 1
brady has won 3 rings with no-name WRs, he has the TD record when he finally got a good WR in moss, he has turned welker from no-name to a pro-bowler, his career rating is just 0.1 lower than that of manning's which so many manning fans love to fluant, and brady is being best right about now, and overall there avg stats are about the same. want proof? read em and weep manning fans.
i did this by taking away the 2010 season stats except for QB rating, then dividing it by the # of seasons they have played as a starter
brady: 3855 yds 7.4 YPA 28 TDs 12 Ints 63.6% Comp% QB Rating 94.7
manning: 4177 yds 7.6 YPA 30 TDs 15 Ints 64.9% Comp% QB Rating 94.9

if you ask me, these stats are overall similar, and when u throw in 3 Rings 14-4 vs 1 ring and 9-9, i would have to say that overall brady is better

GO PATS AND BRADY!

  • 98 Replies
JohnnyUnitas
offline
JohnnyUnitas
172 posts
Nomad

I do hate Brady, but you can't take all the credit from him i say its about 60% talent, 40% coaching.

Zultimategamer2000
offline
Zultimategamer2000
430 posts
Nomad

Yeah jdogg....
Your "great coach" Bill Belichick

He failed with the Browns. His career record without brady is 52-63.

Bill has ZERO rings without Brady. He was 5-11 in 2000 when he had Drew Bledsoe as his starting QB.

JohnnyUnitas
offline
JohnnyUnitas
172 posts
Nomad

I hate the Patriots anyway. Pats vs. Pack in the SB. Pack wins!! period

jdoggparty
offline
jdoggparty
5,860 posts
Nomad

I do hate Brady, but you can't take all the credit from him i say its about 60% talent, 40% coaching.


I'm not taking all the credit. I'm just giving it to Manning

He failed with the Browns. His career record without brady is 52-63.


The Browns were terrible. You have to have at least one good player, and that is Brady. All I'm saying is he made the rest of the team great for Brady. Manning made the team great on his own.
JohnnyUnitas
offline
JohnnyUnitas
172 posts
Nomad

lol. Nice. I respect Brady altogether, but still hate him

pauler94
offline
pauler94
2,513 posts
Nomad

I don't respect Brady at all. I think he's a horrible person and a bad sport. Every time he makes a mistake (which is very little nowadays...) everybody's like "oh, that's ok, he's Tom Brady" and it drives me mad.

Zultimategamer2000
offline
Zultimategamer2000
430 posts
Nomad

how is brady a bad sport? the jets are the bad sports. did u see what they did b4 the game?

pauler94
offline
pauler94
2,513 posts
Nomad

how is brady a bad sport?

"I hate the Jets" - Tom Brady. Case closed. Even if you don't like a team, you don't come out in public like he did and say something like that without at least saying you respect them, even if you're lying.
the jets are the bad sports

Maybe a little bit, but every time Rex said that "it's personal" between him and someone else (Manning and then Belichick), he made it known that he deeply respects them.
did u see what they did b4 the game?

I don't remember if they did anything unsportsmanlike before the game. But after the game, Bart Scott was just saying "F*** you" to all of the people that make fun of the Jets. I'm a huge Jets fan. My school's full of Pats and Giants fans. They all asked for it.
Showing 91-98 of 98