ForumsThe TavernIs a plane more dangerous than a car?

122 29086
chiliad_nodi
offline
chiliad_nodi
637 posts
Peasant

No, that is ridiculous.
You mess up in a plane, you go doun.
You mess up in a car, 7 people go down.

You mess up in a plane, you have 3,000 feet to catch yourself
You mess up in a car well...

Your engine fails in a plane, you glide to earth.
Your engine fails on earth you crash.

Anybody can get a licence, but a pilot's licence takes hours of flight time.

In a car, there is no control tower...

  • 122 Replies
David858
offline
David858
181 posts
Nomad

The plane is much safer then the car, because it would be so hard for someone to crash it these days when airport securite is so tight. while someone could walk up to you in your car and just shot you.

JMV
offline
JMV
63 posts
Nomad

Statistically you are in much greater risk of dying from a car accident than an airplane accident...

BloodySunday
offline
BloodySunday
5 posts
Nomad

I believe most of you fellows are not seeing the fact as to why the plane is supposedly safer.

Of course statistics will show that the plane is much safer than a car or similar vehicle. Why? Almost every person (over the age of twenty) in America has a car; how many of those citizens own some sort of aviation vehicle? There you go. If every person in America owned a plane, and used say plane as much as there average transportation, there would be just as many (or almost just as many) accidents in the air as there are on the ground.

Furthermore... well, that is actually the whole of it, the simple fact that most people drive cars over planes, that we come to the fact that a car will bring about more injuries/fatalities than any plane ever will.

But what, in all honesty, is the point of this topic? Really no one is going to say that a car is safer than a plane, since when one is in a car there are so many ways for them to be injured/killed that is in no fault of their own.

RsC
offline
RsC
424 posts
Shepherd

well... actually it doesnt really matter its about the driver/pilot who is driving the plane/car.. but the only thing is that a car is on ground so its safer...when you make an accident you still got your seatbelt and airbag too protect you and if a plane falls down than only thing you can do is hope or use a parachute but still you lost a plane..

DivineDarkness
offline
DivineDarkness
1,226 posts
Nomad

Most of the plane accidents that ever happen are on landing or take off, where talking IN THE AIR TO THE GROUND

DivineDarkness
offline
DivineDarkness
1,226 posts
Nomad

Most of the plane accidents that ever happen are on landing or take off, where talking IN THE AIR TO THE GROUND

DivineDarkness
offline
DivineDarkness
1,226 posts
Nomad

Most of the plane accidents that ever happen are on landing or take off, where talking IN THE AIR TO THE GROUND

Shenko
offline
Shenko
1,059 posts
Treasurer

yeah plane wins

xKimchix
offline
xKimchix
323 posts
Nomad

Of course statistics will show that the plane is much safer than a car or similar vehicle. Why? Almost every person (over the age of twenty) in America has a car; how many of those citizens own some sort of aviation vehicle? There you go. If every person in America owned a plane, and used say plane as much as there average transportation, there would be just as many (or almost just as many) accidents in the air as there are on the ground.


^This^

And if everyone owned a plane, there will be more OH THE HUGE MANATEES.
MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

Even taking that into account, a simple correlation of odds, which accounts for variations in numbers, shows that aircraft are far safer than cars. It's not a matter of there being more cars so the odds are increased, odds stay the same regardless of mass numbers. The issue with cars is that there is congestion, pedestrian traffic, multiple distractions, people driving who are unfamiliar with their vehicle, people who are not expert drivers, and people who drive vehicles with poor maintenance records.

In commercial aircraft this is mostly eliminated. There is, for all intents and purposes, no traffic (with the exception of at the airports and there's a team of experts directing that traffic), the planes have much stricter maintenance guidelines to reduce the risk of malfunction, the operators (pilots) are not only experts, but are augmented by extremely advanced computer software.

MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

Sorry for DP:

yeah plane wins


Way to necro a thread with a spam post. Next time try to refrain from necro's unless you have substantially more than 3 words to add to the thread.
derek13756
offline
derek13756
168 posts
Nomad

a air plane because theres less traffic in the air

XXAlienGirlXX
offline
XXAlienGirlXX
810 posts
Nomad

The point is, most car crashes include drunk and violent drivers, and airplanes include huge families, and children and babies.
I think that it would be safer to be in a plane then a car since anything can happen in a car, one false move and you crash into another car or swirl to the edge, and if you let go to the steering wheel thing on an airplane you wont die immediately, you still have time to fix whatever you did. Airplanes also have parachutes. Cars do not. Depending on the location, quality, traffic, wheather, and soberness (is that even a word?) it can determine which one is safer.

MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

The point is, most car crashes include drunk and violent drivers


Actually only 7% of car crashes are related to alcohol, although those 7% account for roughly 35% of fatalities.

airplanes include huge families, and children and babies.


Umm... not correct. People are actually less likely to be traveling with children on airplanes than they are in motor vehicles.

Airplanes also have parachutes.


Yep. Every time I get on an airplane the stewardess instructs me on the proper use of my parachute... /sarcasm
BenTheBozer
offline
BenTheBozer
815 posts
Nomad

Statiscally speaking a plane is far more safer then a car, and here is something to scare everyone the planes wings are glued on.

Showing 76-90 of 122