ForumsWEPR[concluded] Was Jesus real?

453 74731
holt24
offline
holt24
1,133 posts
Nomad

This is not about whether or not he was the son of God but whether he actually existed.Most atheists agree that he did live but there are some who don't so what are you're thoughts?

  • 453 Replies
darkrai097
offline
darkrai097
858 posts
Nomad

I'm an atheist and I think there's a good chance he existed, however I do not believe he was the son of God.

cowmaster1
offline
cowmaster1
676 posts
Shepherd

When you die you either go to Heaven, Hell or Purgatory. Then you stay there for eternity. What am I not articulating?


Not 100% true. Purgatory is a spiritual cleansing with fire preparing you see God and go to heaven, you live for eternity for eternity. And if you to hell you're in there for eternity
MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

When you die you either go to Heaven, Hell or Purgatory. Then you stay there for eternity. What am I not articulating?


Purgatory isn't in your source material.
As for the eternity bit I'm saying that is unjust because of being eternal. You said the only way to get sent to hell is a denial of God, which in itself is riddled with it's own injustices and displays a pettiness on Gods part. I then pointed out what if the person changed there mind after the fact. You said they get out. Then I pointed out that would mean it's not eternal. You reversed your statement and said you don't get out, which again puts it back to an unjust system.

As far as human nature goes, we don't have to apologize for being human, and that's about all I have to say about it.


Considering many of the sins are really just human nature and we have to apologize for them then yes you do.

The argument of original sin put to music by a former evangelical minister.
Dan Barker - Can't Win With Original Sin
MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

Here's Hitchens saying pretty much the same thing I've been saying here.
Christopher Hitchens - Christianity is NOT Moral (1)
Christopher Hitchens - Christianity is NOT Moral (2)

Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

Well I'm too lazy to watch the second one, but the first one was very thought provocative.

samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

Not 100% true. Purgatory is a spiritual cleansing with fire preparing you see God and go to heaven, you live for eternity for eternity.


Ignoring the fact that purgatory isn't necessarily biblical, if such a place did exist couldn't all souls receive this cleansing therefore removing the need for hell?
Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

Ignoring the fact that purgatory isn't necessarily biblical, if such a place did exist couldn't all souls receive this cleansing therefore removing the need for hell?


If you're going to hell you're beyond help, which makes no sense when your God is omnipotent.
samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

If you're going to hell you're beyond help, which makes no sense when your God is omnipotent.


Exactly! And if a cleansing is required then what's the point of being a Christian on Earth? I thought the whole point was so that you would be clean before God.
Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

I guess God just likes that new car smell... who doesn't?

cowmaster1
offline
cowmaster1
676 posts
Shepherd

First thing, cleansing isn't necessarily needed. You are going to make mistakes in life, christian or not, that's what reconciliation is for, but most christians i know never go. Secondly, if you aren't christian, you have no relationship with God, thus no possible way to be cleaned. To be cleaned, you need to have a relationship. Why should one who denies God and have no relationship with him deserve to be cleaned? Chances are there may be exceptions but, it's not my call.

now im sure you'll find some crazy example thatll be on the borderline, so swing away.

samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

Why should one who denies God and have no relationship with him deserve to be cleaned?


For all have sinned and feel short of the glory of God.

We deserve it as much as you seeing as how we both have sinned and have both been saved by grace. What of someone who never heard the word of god? Wasn't limbo abolished recently?
Cinna
offline
Cinna
753 posts
Nomad

What of someone who never heard the word of god?


He is saved. I guess ignorance IS bliss.
cowmaster1
offline
cowmaster1
676 posts
Shepherd

What of someone who never heard the word of god?

Thats the exception/crazy example that i was talking about. Its not my call.

We deserve it as much as you seeing as how we both have sinned and have both been saved by grace.

I'm not sure what you believe, but atheists don't deserve it. Again, its not my call
samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

Thats the exception/crazy example that i was talking about.


Crazy? Logically more people in human history haven't heard it then the ones who have, think native Americans.

I'm not sure what you believe, but atheists don't deserve it.


I believe in many things but the Christian God is not one of them, why exactly does that make me undeserving? Because I want proof?
cowmaster1
offline
cowmaster1
676 posts
Shepherd

Crazy? Logically more people in human history haven't heard it then the ones who have, think native Americans.


So what am i supposed to do about it. You can't blame christianity because there were a hell of a lot of missionaries converting the native americans too

I believe in many things but the Christian God is not one of them, why exactly does that make me undeserving? Because I want proof?

Your disbelief.
Showing 151-165 of 453