ForumsWEPRQuestion for Christians- All dogs go were?

64 8322
314d1
offline
314d1
3,817 posts
Nomad

To start out the post with something vague to allow for more wide away, were to the souls of none human animals go, if they were to exist? Heaven and hell are apparently only for humans do the the "original sin", so are animals who did not participate doomed to the same fate?

If animals do not have souls, then were does there personality come from? Going back to the example of dogs, some are energetic, some are calm, and actually pretty much as different as humans. This would of course, make since that there is no such thing as souls, but not if there is.

Then, if beasts go straight to paradise, then why does the god not extend the same kindness to humans?

  • 64 Replies
FallenSky
offline
FallenSky
1,813 posts
Peasant

Well it is common cutesy on the internetz to read the OP before posting....

I know about internet courtesy; I'm just used to going right through to were the action is.
It's a bad habit of mine that made me quit the WEPR years ago. In fact, today's my very first day back on WEPR, so excus my rudeness, I'll remember to be more courteous from now on.
You see; in the AMW, it is not necessary to read Ops as subject are light hearted and prone to change every now and then; I guess the years I spent there lead me astray from common netiquette ^^.

Somewhat49
offline
Somewhat49
1,606 posts
Nomad

I know about internet courtesy; I'm just used to going right through to were the action is.
It's a bad habit of mine that made me quit the WEPR years ago. In fact, today's my very first day back on WEPR, so excus my rudeness, I'll remember to be more courteous from now on.
You see; in the AMW, it is not necessary to read Ops as subject are light hearted and prone to change every now and then; I guess the years I spent there lead me astray from common netiquette ^^.

what happened to the topic All Dogs Go Where?
FallenSky
offline
FallenSky
1,813 posts
Peasant

what happened to the topic All Dogs Go Where?

Hmm, oh, right; I already gave my answer and since nothing new has been posted we're just disgressing about my little misbehaving.

Somewhat49
offline
Somewhat49
1,606 posts
Nomad

Hmm, oh, right; I already gave my answer and since nothing new has been posted we're just disgressing about my little misbehaving.

ooooooooooohhh ok. well i alreay gave my opinion of this so i'll be waiting for someone elses opinion to be posted so i can coment lol
cddm95ace
offline
cddm95ace
165 posts
Nomad

The bible does not say anything about that, so I can not say. It is one of those things we will only find out when we get to heaven. I personally hope that animals will be in heaven, but I can't give biblical evidence for it.

darthdave9
offline
darthdave9
110 posts
Nomad

Dog Narnia

Humans go to Narnia, dogs go to dog Narnia.

skarl
offline
skarl
250 posts
Nomad

it's hard to say where dogs go. the writers of the bible didn't see this as a important subject, they often refer to dogs if they want to tell that someone is not nice. another one: snakes.

if someone goes to heaven, he\\she is supposed to be happy there.

some people can't be happy without there dog.

4 options:

-people forget they had a dog on earth.

-the dog goes to heaven too.

-people get a something witch is verry like the dog they had, and are happy with that.

-something completely else happens. possible the most likely option.

314d1
offline
314d1
3,817 posts
Nomad

That doesn't explain what happens to all other beasts when they die, like say a non domestic animal. How would that work? So like a wolf, who never has any contact with humans, what would happen to it? Or say an atheist's dog? Do they go to hell for something they could not control?

goumas13
offline
goumas13
4,752 posts
Grand Duke

Usually mainstream Christianity says that animals are soulless, so I presume they go nowhere.

MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer
Zydrate
offline
Zydrate
383 posts
Farmer

Animals are considered lesser beings to the Christian religion. As for where their 'entities' go when they die... They simply do not care.

I am a christian but I still don't care much for animals. I love the pets I have but I've lost three cats to illness in my lifetime. Never cried for any of them.

Freakenstein
offline
Freakenstein
9,504 posts
Jester

Animals are considered lesser beings to the Christian religion. As for where their 'entities' go when they die... They simply do not care.


Oh really? Why does your religion think animals are of lesser beings? What makes them lesser than us, when clearly some animals are far better developed than us in some aspects? And how do you know their entities do not care where they go? That is in a sense "speaking for them". How do you, or your religion, know how their plans go?
Freakenstein
offline
Freakenstein
9,504 posts
Jester

That quote really has no point here. The smartest dog has a substantial difference against the stupidest man. Although I'm not very sure what you're getting at here.

MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

that someone who believes an Omnipotent being running the universe has enough time to make a house call isn't that intillegent.


Why wouldn't he have time to make a house call? If he can't that would go against his omnipotence.
skarl
offline
skarl
250 posts
Nomad

'look at the birds, none of them dies if the father doesn't want to. why complain, while you are much better than the birds?' (free translation, I havn't an englisch bible 'round here.

Showing 46-60 of 64