ForumsWEPR10-year old refuses to stand for The Pledge Of Allegiance

186 30047
dudeguy45
offline
dudeguy45
2,917 posts
Peasant

[url=http://www.arktimes.com/articles/articleviewer.aspx?ArticleID=2f5d7a3b-c72a-446b-8d20-3823aa79c021]


What do you think?

  • 186 Replies
75Greeno
offline
75Greeno
130 posts
Peasant

this kid did what his parents told him to do to get on the 6:00 news that is all no free speech deal just some parents getting the 15 min of fame through the kid who will have to deal with this for ever

thepyro222
offline
thepyro222
2,150 posts
Peasant

No matter what we think, the court's going to rule it as a freedom of speech thing, (I didn't read the whole article.)

75Greeno
offline
75Greeno
130 posts
Peasant

yes that is the way they will rule to bad they should make the kid do community service for wasting the court's time

German3945
offline
German3945
996 posts
Nomad

it's not even going to court.

there's no charges that can be charged for what happened, because nothing happened.

it's not something that anyone needs to be concerned with.


make the kid do community service for wasting the court's time

read the article before you comment again.

both of you.
thepyro222
offline
thepyro222
2,150 posts
Peasant

I was just stating what normally happens in these situations...

75Greeno
offline
75Greeno
130 posts
Peasant

ya calm down german it is no big deal you don't have to go all crazy on us

loganada
offline
loganada
186 posts
Nomad

I dont say the pledge of the allegiance! I respect america and the flag. im also atheist, but i dont say it because of that, i say it because its a pledge and pledges should only be said once, right?

jkmadman1
offline
jkmadman1
1,066 posts
Nomad

Wow he is good at sticking with things and is pretty smart.

valkyrie1119
offline
valkyrie1119
1,720 posts
Nomad

The pledge is an interesting symbol of the American Government. Because America has gained a certain Notoriety in the recent years, the pledge symbolizes something that is not nearly as good as it can be (i.e. the government, as well as freedom and liberty, but there is nothing wrong with either of those.) In essence, the government is far from perfect. However, it is a citizen's basic right to Freedom of Speech, and I suppose this would fall under that category. I simply go silent while the rest of the class says the words "...one nation under God," because I do not see myself as a religious person, and therefore that is my right.

I think that he is justified for not desiring to stand for the Pledge.

AnaLoGMunKy
offline
AnaLoGMunKy
1,573 posts
Blacksmith

yes that is the way they will rule to bad they should make the kid do community service for wasting the court's time


So if it DID go to court, you would want to punish the kid for being... and lets get this straight... taken to court... really. Did you think that thru?

Hypothetical situation of someone accused of stealing...
"we think you stole this tv/pc/donkey rubarb, but the CCTV footage proves your innocence.. but we gonna make you scrub donky doo doo cos you have to make up for our mistake of spending money taking you to court in the first place... we is smart... hu hu huh..."
VoteSocialist
offline
VoteSocialist
950 posts
Nomad

I pledge but I like to change the words around.

For instance:

"...one nation, under Bob..."

"...to the United Socialist States of America..."

"...socially divisable, with liberty and justice for some..."

"...with liberty and justice for Bob..."

Dissolution
offline
Dissolution
22 posts
Nomad

"...one nation, under Bob..."

"...to the United Socialist States of America..."

"...socially divisable, with liberty and justice for some..."

"...with liberty and justice for Bob..."


How old are you exactly?
XVERB
offline
XVERB
3,137 posts
Nomad

How old are you exactly?


first maybe second grade. Thats when i did that.
communist09
offline
communist09
259 posts
Nomad

He is either smart, or he soaks up information from his parents like a sponge. Either way, he has the right not to stand up. Even though not standing up won't change anything, standing up has the same effect. He's 10, what is he supposed to do to protest?

Bronze
offline
Bronze
2,417 posts
Shepherd

its a pledge and pledges should only be said once, right?


Told my friends the same thing, even though I stood for it everytime > <

This story is a meh to me, when I went to school you would have days where nobody stood up. There was even a day that people would put tape over their mouth for gay rights.

I will give the kid credit for one thing, smart or not, he was brave. Kids that age enjoy being mean, and a boy standing up for homos would be a likely target for bullying.
Showing 46-60 of 186