God in no way made the fruit seem desirable; He did the exact opposite.
Gen 3:6 When the woman saw that the fruit of the tree was good for food and
pleasing to the eyeThe fifth chapter does say that Adam was 130 years old at the birth of his son Seth, but there is no reference to the amount of time that passes between Adam's creation and Eve's creation, Eve's creation and the Fall and expulsion from Eden
This further substantiates the claim that it was a trap. If it wasn't they would've just sat there literally forever, since they'd all stay immortal. Additionally, without a point of reference for how long such a test would persist, He could've seen if they were obedient for any amount of time and rewarded all of humanity with paradise. Since He left it open indefinitely, this heavily implies that the test was indeed an unwinnable trap.
The teacher suspecting (or, in this case, knowing) beforehand that the student will fail does not invalidate the student's right to prove himself.
One who believes their child possesses enough sense, maturity, and intelligence not to eat something which they have been told in clear terms will kill them?
Adam and Eve failing was not God's goal.
These statements directly conflict. If God KNEW they would fail, then He did NOT believe they were ready. Knowing that they're not ready, and setting it up anyway, means that it WAS the goal.
And, the Garden of Eden situation is more of a parent-pretending-to-walk-away-but-in-reality-is-still-watching-through-the-door-that-just-looks-it's-completely-closed type metaphor....
No it isn't. He left and returned later, actively searching for them. A parent looking through the door usually stops the danger, or at least shows awareness. The Binding of Isaac is the pretending-to-walk-away version.
And, even if they had refused the suggestion to eat the fruit, they still would have acquired a knowledge of good and evil, just from a different perspective.
No they wouldn't. Evil (or the concept of evil) didn't exist there. Literally everything they'd ever encountered was deemed "good" just by existing.
this makes it sound like Adam and Eve were Not Immortal meaning that they Would Die eventually
the verse makes it sound like they hadn't eaten from the tree yet, and if they did, they would then live forever.
There are a few interpretations of the role of that tree. Some argue that they, and all things, were created immortal in the simple sense (unable to die of age), but not imperviously so. Others see the tree as the source of their extended lives, but they'd need to keep eating from it in order to stay immortal. Either way, the fruit they ate corrupted the immortality. The tree of life would've essentially acted as an antidote at that point, meaning that if they ate it, they wouldn't learn the consequence of being disobedient because the inherent penalty would go away.
However, the fact that it didn't occur to Him to simply destroy or remove the tree, or at least revoke its restorative powers temporarily, to me, implies a different story. As others have pointed out, for Him to add something pleasing to the eye that allows an opportunity to challenge his own authority seems VERY counterproductive. In some early interpretations of the creation myth, El is the creator God who made the universe and everything, Jehovah is a war demon, and there's a goddess of wisdom among many other gods. El allowed Jehovah to govern the earth, but when he wasn't looking, the goddess of wisdom planted some heavenly trees of knowledge and life as gifts to the humans. Powerless to remove them, Jehovah instructed the humans not to touch them. When he left, she came in to successfully encourage their curiosity, but they had only taken the first fruit when Jehovah returned. He set up a firmament to bar any further celestial interference. Knowing that he would be unable to stop the second fruit's power, he barred the humans by physical force and induced suffering, etc.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A lot of the arguments are both cleared up and muddled further in the JW interpretation that God has the ability to know everything, but does not use it. It's like he has an infinite library of everything, but chooses which books to read.